Reviews

Do the Birds Still Sing in Hell? by Horace Greasley

charlotte_rach's review

Go to review page

challenging dark emotional hopeful informative inspiring sad medium-paced

4.0

talitha2021's review

Go to review page

2.0

It was OK. Interesting story just not sure I quite believe it. As the author would tell it he’s the best lover a woman could know, with an incredibly large penis and the ability to restore the morale of 3,000 POW with his sexual exploits. It’s a cross between My Dad Wrote a Porno and The Great Escape.

opaline's review

Go to review page

4.0

Probably a bit embellished from the truth but a good story. Not a challenging read and I found myself wanting to know what happens next. Quite a few graphic descriptions of what he got up to with Rosa, probably not really necessary to go into so much detail.....

habmsm's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous dark emotional hopeful informative inspiring reflective sad tense fast-paced

4.75

unnecessary graphic sex scenes

keelija's review

Go to review page

4.0

An incredible story. There were multiple times when you just can’t comprehend that you are reading a real life story. Sometime the sexual stuff was a bit graphic for my taste but knowing what the author wanted to tell the world, I get it. It really face you head on with the incomprehensible pain and brutality that people can show one another as well as the power of the human spirit and dignity. Incredible read. Spent the last 50 pages just sobbing with every emotion possible :)

spencesational's review

Go to review page

5.0

If you only read one book this year, make sure it's this one. Through the hell and devastation of war comes a true, love story that will pull even the hardiest of heart strings. Be prepared to go through every emotion; anger, laughter, joy and sadness as you discover the true meaning of friendship, love and loyalty.

The last ten chapters are the most gripping and really immerse you in the story. This has become my new favourite book. I would love to know what happened to Horace after the war but then I doubt, that with the greatest respect, it could better this.

If this isn't made into a film I'll be surprised (and dumbfounded). If it is, I'll be the first in the queue at the cinema.

The only downside for me is that I fear now, this will be the benchmark for every other book I read, and I will be utterly disappointed.

Amazing.

danni_chambers67's review

Go to review page

adventurous challenging informative slow-paced

1.0

I hated this book. I was very excited going into this book and was looking forward to reading it. And it fell so far short of my expectations.

The tone of this book is so bad. They start the book with the 'real' author saying he only told the real and true story of the man this is about Horance Greasley. However, it doesn't feel like that at all. There feels like this massive disconnect. I felt absolute no emotions for the main guy. He didn't feel like a real person and none of the situations felt real. I think this is in part to the writing it just felt off. Making none of the book interesting.

This book felt like Horance Greasley trying to re-live his best days. And it felt of. And also the sexual content made this is uncomfortable and I could not read it. There is also so many misogynistic comments that also made this so uncomfortable to read. It felt like we didn't get to know the love interest other than her looks.

Overall, hated this book and will never read this book again.

Expand filter menu Content Warnings

mrdavid205's review

Go to review page

4.0

This was one of the most unusual and singular WWII stories I have ever read. It tells the story of Horace Greasley who spent nearly five years in captivity at various German POW camps in conditions ranging from the barely adequate through the appalling to the frankly inhuman. Now I am not going to talk about the story because it doesn't deserve to be spoilt in any way. What I will say is that the writing is at times, visceral and frankly very uncomfortable to read as he describes the conditions he and his colleagues were faced with. Believe me, he spares no details. What he also does not spare any details about is his sexual prowess which he clearly considered to be amazing and central to his whole psyche. At times it reads like an over heated Victorian novella and in most cases it is completely unnecessary to go in to so much detail. For this reason you should not leave it anywhere near an easily offended maiden aunt! All that being said, if you can cope with the level of detail in both cases it is a fascinating, worthwhile and inspiring read.

booksandmacchiatos's review against another edition

Go to review page

Gestopt op bladzijde 76.
Wat een verschrikkelijk grof taalgebruik. Ik heb het gevoel dat de ghostwriter een te sensatie-zoekend tintje aan het verhaal van een oude man probeert te geven, erg jammer, maar dit ga ik geen 300 bladzijdes volhouden.

kolakubez07's review

Go to review page

5.0

After visiting Auschwitz, reading this book you could truly get a sense of how people felt and what they had to endure. Such a sad and cruel time but with a lovely story.