Scan barcode
bethtate's review against another edition
3.0
This was an interesting memoir. The author, a white man, spoke of his experiences growing up in a multiracial household with four adopted children of color and how this impacted him and his siblings.
mskathykhang's review against another edition
3.0
3.5 stars
Reflections of a white biological son in a family with transracial adopted siblings.
White saviors looking for a warm fuzzy story about saving children, beware. This is not it.
This also isn’t an indictment of adoption, but it is a fascinating perspective.
Reflections of a white biological son in a family with transracial adopted siblings.
White saviors looking for a warm fuzzy story about saving children, beware. This is not it.
This also isn’t an indictment of adoption, but it is a fascinating perspective.
mishacoleman's review against another edition
1.75
Overall, I did not enjoy this book. I wanted something else out of it. More voices of color, I guess. But Guterl's adoptive siblings are awful quiet. That may simply be out of respect, not speaking for them, but I get a much stronger sense of his (white) parents. It ends up feeling kinda navel-gazy and white-guilty. When, as adults, his older Korean/white sister calls him on a racist pattern, he seems to shut down, thinking their relationship is over. The Guterl parents are rendered as 1970s idealistic liberals, committed to race blindness throughout. The siblings' reactions and identities are not available.
jbl7701's review against another edition
4.0
I always find memoirs interesting. Family memoirs can be tricky because it is one person’s perception/truth and within the same family experiences and memories can vary greatly. Overall I enjoyed the book but had a hard time with how the author referred to his blended family of biological and adopted children from different races as a “failed experiment”. I found the writing style to be uneven. Many of the things I didn’t like about the book other reviewers touched on already. About 25 pages into the book, I realized I worked with Sheryl years ago for a brief period of time. The special license plate was how I figured it out.
lottie1803's review against another edition
challenging
emotional
informative
reflective
medium-paced
3.5