Reviews

The Selfless Act of Breathing by J.J. Bola

korrick's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

Suicide. Now there's a topic to mull over during dinner. Despite having lived with a brain that's been telling me to kill myself for the last twenty years, I don't consider myself an expert in the subject. Indeed, given suicide's inherent characteristics, I wouldn't say anyone could be so and still remain among the living. Long story short, the field of view is eternally subjective, and with such a charged, still largely taboo on the Occidental side of things topic at hand, if you encounter a piece of literature that purposefully seeks it out, rather than tacks it on to a dangling plotline or less than credible character development in order to smooth over an incoming flaw, you're dealing with something unique. Brave, even. Still, not only have I dealt with my fair share of days lived under a depressive episode, I've also read a reasonable number of books, and when it comes to fixing the trajectory of self-annihilation into print, there are certain things that work and certain things that don't. For me, this book fell into more of the latter than the former, but I still admire it for the topics it chose to tackle, especially ones that are oh so pertinent to the 21st century and yet (or perhaps because of that) are so unlikely to show up on the bestseller lists. An exercise in weighing individual evaluation against the communal sphere of influence, then. In reviews, we can achieve little else.

In case you haven't figured it out by now, I'm one of those incessantly annoying critics when it comes to the whole 'show not tell' side of writing. It's a tool that's served me well both in my own writing and evaluating that of others, and until there comes a time when narratives take a deep dive and make resembling Wikipedia articles the fashion, I'll continue to adhere to it. Certain topics of course can veer away from the principle and do just fine, but when it comes to a work that aims to be a meditation on whether or not to take one's life, it's not unfair for me to expect a certain level of measured introspection without a great deal of bangs and booms. What I found was a mirroring plot trajectory with first person reminiscing interwove with third person present recountals, and while the attempts at a certain style of prose were appreciated, I cared more about how the writing chose to portray the evolution of suicidal ideation, something that I myself am more than familiar with. In the end, while I was able to follow the narrative well enough and certain plot events and thought digressions were more intriguing than not, especially when delving into the complications of being Black on both sides of the Atlantic, there were too many climaxes and not enough resolutions for a work taking on so many heavy topics in less than 300 pages. As I said earlier, there is certainly a need for a work such as this taking on such concerns in an extremely 21st century, and I more than appreciate the author's intent. However, the piece as story did not work for me, and I've lived long enough to know that it doesn't do well to continue to dwell on that more than it takes time to write this review, especially with subject material such as this.

If you told me what would happen in my life between the time I started writing this review and the time I finished it, I would lose a good week of sleep in tormented expectation. As it stands, I have come through it all relatively unscathed, and I find myself ever more appreciative of having a small, yet solid community whom I can come to in times of trauma and trust to aid me in my path towards healing. The main character's descent happens part and parcel due to the fracturing of his community, from the most intimate of familial relations to the most chaotic of strangers finding a home in each other, and while I didn't see the point in piling on so many events that were each in and of themselves strong enough to crush someone entirely in so close a succession, I do commend the accurate portrayal of cause and effect. In any case, while I would prefer not to contribute to the work's less than stellar average rating, if I start hedging my bets now, I will have less room in which to properly evaluate future reads in any particularly credible sense. So, if you're thinking about reading this, take into consideration the trigger warnings, both encompassed by the book summary and otherwise (discussions of sexual assault, depictions of racism, drug abuse, misogyny, queerphobia, etc) and choose accordingly. This didn't prove to be the read that I needed to convince me to keep on living. But it may very well end up being that for someone else.

christinag5's review against another edition

Go to review page

dark emotional reflective sad

3.5

The story was beautifully written and touches on important topics like mental health, parental loss, being a refugee, poverty, etc. I finished it all in one morning (albeit bc my library hold was close to expiring). The storytelling method was interesting, with the two interspersed storytellings in different times, locations and 1st vs 3rd person. However, I found the ending to be quite abrupt, with many gaps on how we got there from where we last saw our MC Michael. Additionally, I could not get past the way Michael perceived and interacted with women throughout the novel, it was often uncomfortable. For example lusting after college aged girl Miranda who was in a relationship while he is fully an adult teacher; aggressively trying to not permit Belle, who he had met at the strip club, to go back to dancing when she needed to pay her rent; being rude to his mother throughout and not allowing her to be happy and move on 20 years after his father’s death. 

lobnaelgammal's review against another edition

Go to review page

challenging dark emotional sad tense medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? No
  • Loveable characters? It's complicated
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

3.75

irismaybooks's review against another edition

Go to review page

emotional reflective sad medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

5.0

From beyond this lonely feeling, to healing; the selfless act of breathing.

I found this book at my library, and I can say without a doubt that checking it out was the best decision I have made.

At first I found it a little difficult to get into the book, the jump between first and third person and being in England versus America in each chapter was quite jarring, but after understanding what was happening I was completely ensorcelled by the writing and the story.

At the very start of the book it lists Bola's other work, and I knew when I saw he was a poet that the writing would be beautiful; I was not prepared for quite how beautiful. Since this is a library book I was, unfortunately, unable to highlight as I was going along, so I had this app open the entire time to log lines - or entire paragraphs - that just completely captured my heart. 

The writing was beautiful, and I found myself seeing myself in this man's loneliness when by all accounts, we have nothing in common. Loneliness is strange, isn't it? This book fell into my hands at the most perfect time in my life.

I loved the development of relationships, or lack thereof. I loved the exploration of these new experiences in Michael's life, how each new person brought something new to the story even if they were only there for a few pages, a chapter. I loved all of them.

Overall this book was just beautiful.
10/10, I would recommend this book to anyone.

Expand filter menu Content Warnings

read_katie_read's review against another edition

Go to review page

dark emotional sad slow-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character

3.0

The writing is poetic and thoughtful. Overall it’s a very deep meditation on depression and trauma. As someone who deals with depression, it felt incredibly accurate and authentic. But in turn, this means it’s a really depressing and dark novel. I wasn’t in a great place for something like this so my rating is more re my emotional reaction to the book and not the writing. 

mynightsbooked's review against another edition

Go to review page

I wanted to like this book, especially when I saw it compared to Backman's A Man Called Ove and Gyasi's Transcendent Kingdom. I was bored. So bored. And it felt like it was going nowhere at a snails pace.....

sheeena's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

At first, the writing felt disjointed and odd because of the chapters alternating between first and third person narration. It did get some time to get used to but I got past it eventually.
This book gave me all the melancholy feels so definitely make sure you’re in a good headspace before reading it.

The Selfless Act of Breathing follows Michael who leaves London to go on an adventure in the USA. Once his savings run out, he will end his life. From San Francisco to Dallas to Chicago to New York - Michael parties with friends, has sporadic romances, and splurges his money without any efforts of trying to save it.

The writing was so beautiful, I highlighted so many sentences and even whole paragraphs. I may consider buying this novel to add to my shelf. This book is really powerful as Michael feels so real and his feelings are heartbreaking but relatable.

Some of the book did get boring with some of the random characters as they felt a little underdeveloped but that didn’t bug me so much since Michael was a strong character. Overall, I really enjoyed this novel. Thank you so much to Atria for an advanced copy of this book.

ursulamonarch's review against another edition

Go to review page

I came across this at the library, it looked interesting, and it turned out not to be for me.

rachellayown's review against another edition

Go to review page

I received a copy of this book via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Suffocating under the weight of life and past trauma, Michael Kabongo, a Congolese-British teacher, leaves London and goes to America for a last adventure before he ends his life. The novel is set up with alternating timelines: Michael's past life in London, which is narrated in first person, and his trip across America, narrated in third person. At times the prose is beautiful and lyrical, other times it's rather expository, even awkward. But the strength of this novel is in its emotional texture and the way it explores race, love, and what makes a life worth living.

memoriesfrombooks's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

The description of The Selfless Act of Breathing buy JJ Bola speaks of the life of a refugee, the Black experience in London, a loss, a new beginning, and a transformation. However, it leaves out that the main character begins the book contemplating suicide. That aside, the book narrates the story in a two-time line approach, at times first person and at times third person. Not knowing or understanding Michael's "why" for this final journey makes it challenging to follow him as a character.

Read my complete review at http://www.memoriesfrombooks.com/2023/12/the-selfless-act-of-breathing.html

Reviewed for NetGalley.