Scan barcode
mahdijava112's review against another edition
5.0
چندین بار خواستم بوف کور رو بخونم و حجم کمش من رو گول میزد که بعداً هم فرصت خواهم داشت. اما امروز که این کتاب رو تموم کردم دیدم که خوندن این کتاب چندین برابر حجمش وقت و انرژی صرف کرد. گم شدن تو فضای مالیخولیایی و ریتم کندی که هدایت به عمد به تناسب موضوع انتخاب کرده خوندن این کتاب رو فوقالعاده سخت کرده. شرح عشق افلاطونی راوی به زن اثیری که تو بخش دوم به فروپاشی عشق به شکلی زمینی و زشت به زن لکاته میرسه انقدر سخت و طاقتفرسا بود که آخرش به هدایت آفرین گفتم. شاید کتابی نباشه که بتونم تو مدت زمان کم بارها بخونمش اما کتابی هست که مطمئناً تا مدتها تو ذهنم خواهد موند.
year23's review against another edition
dark
sad
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.0
None of these reviews are pointing out the horror this book is - it is the fictional tale of a narcissistic, misogynist and his hatred of women. Check all the trigger warnings, abuse & murder of women.
It’s genuinely horrifying - the misogynistic language throughout - the unabashed hatred of women, and the pathetic and yet all too familiar objective gaze of men and quest for privilege and power over others is what this story is about.
I would never recommend this because trigger warnings abound. But I think if reading - it needs to be in conversation and dialogue. I don’t know what the author’s intent is - and I’m not sure, given when it was written, how it would be received. If the intent was to shed light on the horrors women face from men in a patriarchal society - it does that, in a roundabout way. If it’s to just tell a sick story that involves murder of women by a hateful man, it also does that too - which is why I think, don’t read this in isolation.
It’s essentially a twisted incel post on Reddit. I found myself saying over and over - when will men stop centering themselves as if they are owed the entire world and stop taking their anger and rage at not getting what they think they want out on women.
The rates of violence against women, femincide continue to be huge across the globe. It’s terrifying to be a woman in the world and fiction like this needs to be more openly discussed. I’m genuinely shocked at reviews here - a lot have no mention of the content. Talk about it! If you love it - say why! Just the good writing? It’s not Kafka, come on.
These books scare the crap out of me - cause without conversation and dialogue - I have no clue what people are taking away from it. I highly recommend checking out Townes’ The cultural production of evil for more thoughts on that.
I want to be very clear here - it shouldn’t be banned, people should be able to write and share their stories. And I think this does an excellent job of a character study of how incels in particularly reason their way into destructive thoughts and sometimes dangerous behavior.
My concern here is about how we as readers engage with stories like these. Passively taking it in and just going about our day? I want better for us - I need better for us because this is real ish people are dealing with daily, real lives being destroyed due to violence. This is political and personal.
I read this right after reading Kim Jiyoung, Born 1982 - and it really highlighted the how important these stories are to confronting sexism and the systems that reproduce it and endanger all of us (all genders) as a result (even the MC here is suffering).
I don’t know how to rate this - as I said, any recommendation should come with extreme caution.
If any man in your life says this is their favorite book, RUN.
It’s genuinely horrifying - the misogynistic language throughout - the unabashed hatred of women, and the pathetic and yet all too familiar objective gaze of men and quest for privilege and power over others is what this story is about.
I would never recommend this because trigger warnings abound. But I think if reading - it needs to be in conversation and dialogue. I don’t know what the author’s intent is - and I’m not sure, given when it was written, how it would be received. If the intent was to shed light on the horrors women face from men in a patriarchal society - it does that, in a roundabout way. If it’s to just tell a sick story that involves murder of women by a hateful man, it also does that too - which is why I think, don’t read this in isolation.
It’s essentially a twisted incel post on Reddit. I found myself saying over and over - when will men stop centering themselves as if they are owed the entire world and stop taking their anger and rage at not getting what they think they want out on women.
The rates of violence against women, femincide continue to be huge across the globe. It’s terrifying to be a woman in the world and fiction like this needs to be more openly discussed. I’m genuinely shocked at reviews here - a lot have no mention of the content. Talk about it! If you love it - say why! Just the good writing? It’s not Kafka, come on.
These books scare the crap out of me - cause without conversation and dialogue - I have no clue what people are taking away from it. I highly recommend checking out Townes’ The cultural production of evil for more thoughts on that.
I want to be very clear here - it shouldn’t be banned, people should be able to write and share their stories. And I think this does an excellent job of a character study of how incels in particularly reason their way into destructive thoughts and sometimes dangerous behavior.
My concern here is about how we as readers engage with stories like these. Passively taking it in and just going about our day? I want better for us - I need better for us because this is real ish people are dealing with daily, real lives being destroyed due to violence. This is political and personal.
I read this right after reading Kim Jiyoung, Born 1982 - and it really highlighted the how important these stories are to confronting sexism and the systems that reproduce it and endanger all of us (all genders) as a result (even the MC here is suffering).
I don’t know how to rate this - as I said, any recommendation should come with extreme caution.
If any man in your life says this is their favorite book, RUN.
sfox26's review against another edition
challenging
dark
mysterious
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.5
kraegates's review against another edition
challenging
dark
mysterious
reflective
sad
tense
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
elionthesun's review against another edition
Vielleicht wann anders… jetzt ist es zu anstrengend einer eindeutig depressiven Person, die sich nicht helfen zu weiß, zu folgen
nihilisk's review against another edition
3.0
A unique read. I admired the economy of words and the repetition of specific phrases and descriptions throughout. These, along with the subject matter and ‘plot’, slowly create a dense nightmare, like a jet-black pearl.
Presented as confessional/autofiction, the two halves of the book can be viewed as distortions/reflections of one another. Through opium, the narrator steps through time, and it becomes unclear what is ‘real’: the first half, the second, or both. Every character is a mask of the narrator, and the work is an exercise in desire, despair, contempt, and destruction. Do not expect any balm at the end, only a dose of poisoned wine.
Think Inception, via opium, channeled by Edgar Allen Poe’s Iranian cousin. Or, Mulholland Drive, reimagined by a disillusioned Iranian poet. Recommended for fans of the macabre and the poetic, alike.
Presented as confessional/autofiction, the two halves of the book can be viewed as distortions/reflections of one another. Through opium, the narrator steps through time, and it becomes unclear what is ‘real’: the first half, the second, or both. Every character is a mask of the narrator, and the work is an exercise in desire, despair, contempt, and destruction. Do not expect any balm at the end, only a dose of poisoned wine.
Think Inception, via opium, channeled by Edgar Allen Poe’s Iranian cousin. Or, Mulholland Drive, reimagined by a disillusioned Iranian poet. Recommended for fans of the macabre and the poetic, alike.
t_stre's review against another edition
challenging
dark
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0