Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
5.0
This is hands down the best Cinderella adaptation I've EVER read!!!! It combined elements of the original stories in such amazing ways that I didn't see coming. And the reveal near the end!!! 🤯🤯🤯🤯 I literally screamed and had to walk away because I was so (delightfully) shocked!!!!
I loved how Noelle was a bit mischievous and flirtatious from the beginning. None of this "she was never usually like that" nonsense that a lot of female MCs do. And I also like that she was always standing up for herself. The story of Cinderella is hard for me because of the injustice, cruelty, and abuse she endures. I liked that this one was different.
This was part of a Christmas Chronicles series, but it really was a winter tale. I read it in January so it was perfect for that. Other than a few mentions of mistletoe, holly, and peppermint, it didn't have anything to do with Christmas. Again, to me this was a plus because I love winter books, but if you're looking for Christmas then save this until January.
This was just ok. I liked the movie better lol. It was incredibly slow, and I felt Charles' view of women (that they are just as capable as men, etc.) unrealistic coming from a guy from 1902. I also didn't appreciate how him going back was built up as this super emotional thing and then he just .....decides not to. It was super anticlimactic.
This was such an amazing book!! It was thought provoking and illuminating. I've grown up into the American evangelical inerrancy tradition, and I've grown up with the nativity story all my life. This has fresh, biblically and historically accurate information that combined faith with the reality of scholarship. She doesn't delve too deeply into the discrepancies of the narratives but focuses on the beauty of the overall theme: that God loves us so much that he'd do something as surprising as come down as a baby.
It was refreshing and wonderful and I highly recommend it!!
Child death: death of the innocents
Adult/minor relationship: she makes a big deal about Mary being only 12. Most bump it to 14 (which is still not great, when you think of it), and it did leave me feeling rather ill at ease (to be fair, the author is not saying child marriage is a good thing, only it is the reality according to many historians)
It opened with her being hazed by having to take off her bra in front of a ton of drunk guys. It's disgusting that that's sort of sexual harassment /bullying is basically "ok-ed" by the author. The character in question is clearly uncomfortable and it's just so disgusting. No one should ever feel like they need to do something like this.
I read it for new years, but it wasn't white Christmas or new years. It would have been a great book for those days in between, but it was pretty good after too!
I really loved Jack and the Skeffington family. I loved Desiree too, although I felt her character was a little all over the place - the author wanted to make her independent and into things like mechanics and physics, but it just felt like those things were shoe-horned in rather than being naturally part of the story.
Also, neither good nor bad, there was a small spicy scene in this one after two books without them. They seem to be throw away events and I'm not sure why the author has them in since her heart is in the characters and not the spice.