Stronger than the first two books in the series. I actually liked Jude at this point. Cardan was actually fleshed out, given time to shine as more than a troubled young man. Their connection was more believable. My problem with the story is too many conveniences, characters who suddenly change their minds in conflict. I enjoyed the book, but it is not without its small faults.
This was about 100 pages too long. I enjoyed learning about the daily struggles of the time, but I can't say I liked even a single character. Now I am aware that this is not supposed to be a happy ending story that leaves readers satisfied, but I also can't really see the hype around it. There are some good quotes and strong ideas to ponder related to redemption and power relations.
This was a slog and I didn't like it. He has some interesting fun facts about Danish history but the rest of the book is just rehashing the same shit over and over again. I skipped an entire chapter about Christmas. This whole thing could have been a bullet point list, which probably would have been more helpful. He says some gross stuff about women and takes on this persona of the expert on every person in Denmark. Dude, everyone likes candles, blankets, and cake. This isn't Denmark-specific. This book was a boring, fetishizing take on a concept that doesn't need 300 pages.
This was a slog to get through at times. Most chapters focus on the backgrounds of different characters in a town, which was engaging and helped to add at least a bit of complexity. Otherwise, there was so much philosophical exposition that seemed to repeat itself. I wrote down a few lines that spoke to me but as a whole I can't really place what this book was trying to say besides "death is tricky". Maybe I'll change my rating as I process the pages, but I cannot say this is a favorite. Side note, it loses points for having a typical "men writing women" POV making most of the female characters props, boasting about their breast's, and showing horny men as typical, as if they cannot control themselves.
I expected more from this book. It wasn't terrible, but it is forgettable. The twist is not expected per say, but it also doesn't come as a surprise. My experience was lukewarm. I feel as if this is not enough material to analyze beyond the surface level.
I wasn't a huge fan of the first book and this one had many of the same problems, amplified. The writing is so basic, even for a young adult book. Characters' personalities are surface level. The world of the fairies is at least interesting, and I did choose to read the second book in the series. However, this is not a book that sticks with you. It's a quick read.
I got a lot out of this read, but there are so many problems I cannot deal with. A woman giving up her boundaries to have sex with a guy who is literally on his knees because he's horny. Romanticizing domestic violence. A few casual sexist comments. Characters' main personality trait is "troubled." I feel like I should give it another half star because I did connect with it emotionally. But I also want to take a star away for the issues it contains.
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
This book requires an analytic, critical lens of a literature student to get the most out of it. The prose can drag at times but this isn't exactly an action-packed story. The horrors of the Nigerian civil war are on full display. Besides the two women protagonists, I hated every character. Men are truly the scum of the earth.
I'm really debating whether this book deserves 3.5 or 4/5. The story itself is engaging and I loved the setting. All I want is more pirate women who don't fit the "hot girl" stereotype, but I felt these characters lacked enough depth. Amina could be more complex, at times it seems she is just too powerful for there to be any real tension. The pacing is weird; nothing really happens for the first 100 pages, which doesn't bode well for a plot-focused novel. It often felt like there was too much text with not enough substance. All that being said, I did enjoy the tale of adventure. I would be interested to give a sequel a try if it promised more focus on the characters and created a reason for me to care what's happening to them.