Capote’s writing and Scott Brick’s narration drew me into this story, but it was just too upsetting for me to keep reading. True-crime novels are probably not for me.
4 stars for Antsy! This was a very good sequel to her story & I am so glad we got more of her. This had a very good character arc for her. It also seems that McGuire is laying more foundations for what will be happening next in this world.
That being said, the books that take place in "our" world remain not as good as the others. It's difficult to remember who everyone is (I will definitely need to reread them all when #11 comes out) & in this one especially, there was too much going on. I also can't stand Yumi anymore.
But anyway, it was good to be with Kade again & a couple of the other characters. And I just love Antsy.
Re-read 2024: I somehow forgot how much I love this character. This story broke my heart all over again but I love it so much. I’m really excited the next book is also about Antsy! - January 2024
original review: Oh I’m so happy I picked this one up! After not enjoying the last few, I wasn’t sure what to expect, but this was exactly what I wanted from this series. Antsy was an amazing lead. I cried multiple times during her journey. She loses so much in her life but she’s such a pure soul. I want another book with her..
My rankings of all the books so far (starting with my most favorite & going down): - In an Absent Dream - Lost in the Moment & Found - Down Among the Sticks & Bones - Every Heart a Doorway - Across the Green Grass Fields - Beneath a Sugary Sky - Where the Drowned Girls Go - Come Tumbling Down
The last few books of this series have been disconnected from what made them so great to begin with. I’ve never enjoyed the books that take place on our side as much, but even with that knowledge going in, this one fell flat. None of the eeriness is present, though we are told that this school is evil. And the stakes are so low it doesn’t feel triumphant at all when they are jumped over. Lastly, this series starts with the premise that once a door closes, it almost never opens again. That’s one of the big pieces of tension in that first, and subsequent, novellas. But by this point in the series they just open whenever if you want it badly enough? Nah, I don’t like that.
On the up side, I didn’t dislike Cora as much. She’s actually given a little more storyline than just constantly thinking about how she’s The Fat Girl.