I loved this book. It was a 5 star book for me until the ending ruined the perfection. This line alone took it down a star:
"What is a woman but her labor and her children?"
That sentence made me livid. It was totally out a character and a disgusting opinion. No man decides what women are worth.
There were other things at the end that I did not appreciate, but I don't want to spoil it. I will just say that as an atheist, certain crap makes me roll my eyes.
However, I appreciated the humor and sense of community surrounding the church that is very much a central part of this book. I adored these characters like they were my own neighbors. At first it seemed like I had to go to a lot of effort to keep track of everybody, but it was worth the small challenge. I was highly entertained and felt transported to the New York projects in 1969.
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
I could have read each of these women's stories in a more linear fashion, but individually, they were very good and I like the genre bending. This is a good fit for people who like historical fiction with magical realism.
This is a 900 page book. That, in itself, makes it not for everyone, but it is perfect for me because the characters are so endearingly strange. Sometimes the plot is slow and resembles historical political commentary--definitely left leaning. Sometimes it's riveting drama, and people start dropping like Game of Thrones. The story is quite poignant and reflective, but everyone's sexual foibles had me laughing out loud like a loon. There are common John Irving themes: a straight, cisgender man and everyone he loves is part of the LGBTQ community, there's wresting, of course, and writing. And then there are the addition of the quirky ghosts and his girlfriends' reactions to them. The screenplay episodes took a minute for me to get used to, but they make sense when I realize Adam has to remain detached when recounting certain parts of his life. If you like John Irving's other books, this one won't let you down.
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
It was slow getting started for me, but I ended up really liking the story. The book made me think of Where the Wild Things Are. Those who like gothic fiction tied in with fantasy will probably like this one.
Hell itself is comedic--you can never find a pen that works, you're always stepping in deep puddles, the radio only plays songs that you hate, the bar only serves Jägermeister--but life on earth can be surprisingly dark and involves a lot of child abuse, fair warning.
The short chapters, constant small reveals, and switching points of view kept me quickly turning the pages. It was messed up, but I liked it.
I love this author's imagination. She is a go-to author for me. Her characters are also very down-to-earth. This time there featured a pet vulture. I was impressed.
This book speaks to people white-washing history, in this case art, in the worst way, and the hope of marginalized people reclaiming some of that power. Its theme is very current. It was an inspiring and emotional story, even though I thought a little bit of the supernatural was over-the-top. May narcissistic men like Jack always be haunted by their betters.