The change in location took me a second to get used to but i enjoyed this read! I’m set to finish the series before the end of the year. Awaiting the 4th at the library.
I enjoy Kawaguchi’s writing because it’s an easy read. The stories are heartfelt and impactful, more so in the earlier two books but still here. However, I draw issue with how certain details were almost unnecessarily left vague. Why did a character’s sister die of some disease that everyone just “forgot the name of”? The narrative voice is omniscient, no? The sister’s whole story begins because of her sister’s death so just seems weird to dismiss any detail.
the lead up to the battle at spear pillar was really good and I’m disappointed in how quick it ends without a real resolution. Obviously the story always intended to conclude with platinum’s arc. I mean her arc starts in the middle of a volume! It just left more to be desired for Dia and Pearl.
I’ve been curious about non-monogamy and wanting to explore it for myself so this book felt like a sense but approachable intro into more practically poly relationships work. It took a while to get to it and then it was centered mostly around couples finding their way into nm?
As an audiobook, some of the denser parts were harder to take in. I’d love to reflect more on the questions at the ends of the chapters. Some near the end were really interesting. I have a hold for the physical copy at the library so i can note questions for later.
I enjoyed this but wasn’t wowed. I picked it up on a whim at the library, having heard of the story but knowing no details.
I found the narrator voice to be irritating at times. Miles rambled and maybe that is more accurate to what a person would think in the situation, but for what reason do we need to be accurate or realistic? An example, miles would explain at length a feeling or a memory only to tell us, what he feels is nothing like that. Then why include this? The rambles felt unnecessary as they didn’t build the plot or his character very much.
The women have no proper role to play in this story. You could remove Becky and it would be pretty much the same which is a shame. Becky was quintessential helpless dame in need of rescue which is boring.
The author did an alright job creating tension and intrigue but not enough to my liking.
I had high expectations going into this book because of the great reviews I’d heard and a lot of them speak to things I enjoyed while reading. The characters are engaging and really fleshed out. As they start to interweave into each other’s lives, I was ready for the pace to pick, for the plot to take the forefront. But this book moves, appropriately, at the pace of trees. Did this book need to be as long as it was?
In the latter half, I started listening to the audiobook with the text to help speed my way through. I did not find myself itching to keep reading. I’m all here for the environmental justice lens this book takes. Trees and nature are dying and the stark facts given in this book through the lives of the characters are sobering. The writing is beautiful and impactful at points, wordy and superfluous at others.
If you like slow paced books and an ensemble cast, then I’m sure you’ll enjoy it (maybe! idk you!)
Having both perspectives really added to this read. Charlie came to understand himself and his identity and it felt real. I related to some of his struggles. I love him and also Dev they deserve the best okay????
The side characters are sometimes even better than the main guys so that’s a treat too.
I do wish we had some more detailed sex scenes though but that first kiss feels sooo well deserved.