So. I have very mixed feelings about this book. I first read it at age 11 and absolutely loved it, but rereading at the (relatively) older age of 17 - and writing this review at 18 - has given me a different perspective.

Good things: This book is hilarious, and Anne's children are very sweet as little kids. The ending page is very Anne-ish and reminds me of some of the earlier books. Susan is lovable.

Bad things: Some characters read like caricatures/cartoons, esp. Aunt Mary Maria. Shirley's relationship with Susan is just... really strange. Some of the children's episodes veer into the unbelievable or ludicrous (rather than just being fun). Anne and Gilbert's relationship - and troubles thereof - feels forced. I wish Anne was writing more.

Overall, this book isn't as good as the others in the series, but that hasn't ruined my abiding love of Anne (and everything LMM). Will reread at some point (and share with my future children).

"This is no common day, Mrs. Dr. dear," she said solemnly.

"Oh, Susan, there is no such thing as a common day. EVERY day has something about it no other day has. Haven't you noticed?"

---
reread 12/16/2017
reread 3/2/2020