Scan barcode
A review by ghosthermione
Havenfall by Sara Holland
adventurous
dark
emotional
hopeful
mysterious
fast-paced
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
This was a serendipitous find in the New Books section at the library the other day, and I am SO GLAD that I picked it! I got to admit, I mostly fell in love with the cover, and I was sceptical when I started reading it yesterday. But it's now past 3am and I've just devoured it.
The plot was complex enough that I could guess some, but not all, of what was actually happening. The heroine is clever and sympathetic, and her past trauma and reactions were very believable, without me being ever mad at her for it. In YA I too often feel like the protagonist makes mistakes on purpose because the narrative demands it, or because they need to be flawed for it to work. But Maddie made mistakes that made sense in context, weren't down to her age or her trauma (mostly) but to the information she had at the moment. Besides, it was a real page turner and I wanted to keep learning about these worlds and the complex mystery that Maddie had to solve to stay in control of the situation.
The story itself was moving, and interesting throughout, with diverse and well-rounded characters. I liked that the staff was a real part of the story, and the elite was frowned upon by the narration when they looked down on people. I want to see more of these characters, especially Taya! And the novel neatly ties the loose ends while still making me very strongly that I have to have the next one NOW! I absolutely recommend it!
The plot was complex enough that I could guess some, but not all, of what was actually happening. The heroine is clever and sympathetic, and her past trauma and reactions were very believable, without me being ever mad at her for it. In YA I too often feel like the protagonist makes mistakes on purpose because the narrative demands it, or because they need to be flawed for it to work. But Maddie made mistakes that made sense in context, weren't down to her age or her trauma (mostly) but to the information she had at the moment. Besides, it was a real page turner and I wanted to keep learning about these worlds and the complex mystery that Maddie had to solve to stay in control of the situation.
The story itself was moving, and interesting throughout, with diverse and well-rounded characters. I liked that the staff was a real part of the story, and the elite was frowned upon by the narration when they looked down on people. I want to see more of these characters, especially Taya! And the novel neatly ties the loose ends while still making me very strongly that I have to have the next one NOW! I absolutely recommend it!
Moderate: Child abuse, Child death, Confinement, and Mental illness
Minor: Bullying
The MC's backstory involves her witnessing the death/violent kidnapping of her little brother as a child ; and nightmares and recollections of this event. She also shows signs of PTSD although it's not said in so many words. Past school bullying is mentioned multiple times. Confinement/kidnapping: the MC and another child are tied up and held prisoners in a basement by kidnappers. The MC also recalls the death of her little brother which she saw from inside a cupboard, which is described as a stifling, claustrophobic experience