I've loved all of Hannah's books so much but I think this one is my favorite. I loved the Jewish rep as always, and it was great to be back with the Barbanels in Nantucket. It was also cool to have astronomy as the main focus. I enjoyed the moments of staying out with the stars, looking for comets, and just that overall vibe. It was also amazing to see that the book was centered more around women in the field and how important it is for them to be recognized. So many elements were done so well. The moments where Jordan talked about not feeling Jewish enough are super relatable and I felt for her. I valued the important conversations she had with her dad as well and I could feel myself getting emotional. She and Ethan both seemed wiser than 17 and the book had a nice mature note to it while still being YA. Overall, this felt warm and fuzzy and perfect for summer— I loved it so much. Thank you to Penguin Teen for providing me with an e-ARC to read and review!