This book was the best Warriors traveling book I have read. The traveling itself had an interesting purpose, and didnt just spent the whole book wandering place to place and getting stuck. That alone made this book quite good compared to others similar to it, but I also liked how they fleshed out Hawkwing. Hes not a bad cat, but hes aware hes making lots of mistakes and tries to do better, and eventually achieves through his maturity. The ending wasnt my favorite and I wouldve enjoyed a longer story, but this is probably one of my favorite warriors super editions and is a great book. My only complaint is that its characters go out faster than the ones in Game of Thrones.