T. Kingfisher excels at creating memorable, multi-dimensional characters. The protagonists, especially Istvhan and Clara, are rich with personality, and their dynamic is both endearing and compelling. Secondary characters like the other nuns and supporting cast members are distinct and additive to the story, providing depth without overshadowing the main plot. I cared deeply about what happened to them, and their quirks made them easy to describe to a friend. Clara’s resilience and Istvhan’s humor and honor stood out as highlights.

The settings are vivid, particularly the dangerous wilderness and eerie cult-like locations. The descriptions of both mundane and fantastical elements, including the unique creatures, were immersive. While the atmosphere didn’t always hit the "wow" factor that elevates a story to the next level, the world-building pulled me in completely. The tone perfectly balanced dark tension with humor, which kept me engaged.

Kingfisher’s writing is accessible, witty, and full of charm. Her prose is engaging without feeling overly ornate, and the dialogue is sharp and often hilarious. The balance between narration and dialogue felt seamless, making the book an easy and enjoyable read. I loved the humor woven into even the darker moments, and her ability to blend warmth and grotesque elements stood out as a unique signature. This style would absolutely encourage me to pick up another book by her, regardless of genre.

The pacing felt solid, with only a few moments where the story meandered slightly. The plot itself was intriguing and satisfying, with plenty of action, mystery, and romance to keep things moving. While some elements felt familiar compared to other fantasy stories I’ve read, there were enough twists and unique features to make the story feel fresh. The blend of romance and adventure was particularly well done, and the climax was both satisfying and emotional.

The book held my attention remarkably well, thanks to the sharp character interactions and the mysteries surrounding the cult. I found myself wanting to pick it up whenever I had a free moment. The balance between intrigue, action, and romance ensured there was always something to look forward to, and the momentum stayed strong throughout.

The relationships between characters, particularly Istvhan and Clara, felt organic and deeply rooted in their respective backstories. Their actions were consistent with their motives and personalities, and the magic system and world-building were clear and cohesive. I appreciated the balance between providing enough information to understand the world and avoiding unnecessary detail. The rules of the world were maintained, and everything fit together well without any significant plot holes.

The book was an absolute joy to read, blending humor, heart, and action seamlessly. I found it consistently entertaining and satisfying, with a tone that felt both comforting and exciting. While it didn’t reinvent the wheel in terms of fantasy tropes, it executed them so well that it didn’t matter to me.