Scan barcode
A review by bandysbooks
Hera by Jennifer Saint
challenging
tense
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.25
Hera is such an integral character within mythology and she seems like a character who would be perfect for the feminist spin so popular in recent retellings. She is the daughter of Kronos, sister to Zeus, and invested in ruling on Mount Olympus. Once she and Zeus overthrow the titans, Zeus takes power and forces Hera into a position where she must become his wife. In traditional stories, Hera is portrayed as a jealous spouse, exacting unfair revenge on Zeus' lovers and victims as well as any children from these affairs, but what if there was more to it? This is the question that Saint attempts to answer in her recent book.
Sadly, while this book initially seems promising in redefining who Hera is, it eventually does almost the exact opposite. I'm not sure it's intentional, but Saint reinforces the idea that Hera is wholly focused on Zeus and his affairs. It's portrayed as revenge for his forcing her to marry him, but eventually it amounts to the same thing. She doesn't truly punish Zeus who cares little for the women he sleeps with and instead torments the people he victimizes as well as their children in some instances. She lacks the insight to see how her actions affect anyone outside of herself and becomes blinded by her own rage. It felt like a huge fumble in the handling of her character.
Additionally, this book suffered from being overlong. I get that Hera has a massive presence within mythology, but I felt like Saint was summarizing everything she ever did and it made the book tedious in the middle. I think it would've been better served had she focused on 3-5 integral moments and delved more into depth with how they were important to Hera's story. I didn't need to watch her exact revenge on every nymph, mortal, and Demi-god that slept with Zeus.
That said, it wasn't all bad. This book shines when it talks about Hera's relationship with Echidna and her monster children. I loved the parallels drawn between the two of them despite their massive differences. It's one of the few points in the book that Hera actually express any level of compassion or empathy as well. It had the affect of making her feel less flat which is something sorely needed within this narrative.
I also thought that Hera's relationship with Athena was handled well. They aren't friends, but there is a begrudging respect between the two of them and they ally with each other when convenient to their motivations. Unfortunately, I actually felt Athena outshined Hera in the book which is frustrating since Hera is the titular character.
Naomi Frederick narrates the audiobook and is possibly the best part of it. Her voice really brings the characters to life, telling the story in an easy to follow way. I always listen to audiobooks at 2-3x speed, so I appreciated that her narration still sounded good sped up.
All in all, I wanted much more from this book. It felt more like the spark notes summary of Hera as told by Greek mythology instead of a new, fresh take. I don't know if Saint is under an inordinate amount of pressure to turn out a new retelling every year, but I think slowing down her publishing rate and taking the time to really challenge the traditional portrayals of her characters might result in a better book. Clearly, she is a talented writer and well-versed in mythology and I wish she was given time for that talent to shine.
*Thank you to Netgalley, Flatiron Books, and Jennifer Saint for the ARC. This in no way affects the objectivity of my review.
Sadly, while this book initially seems promising in redefining who Hera is, it eventually does almost the exact opposite. I'm not sure it's intentional, but Saint reinforces the idea that Hera is wholly focused on Zeus and his affairs. It's portrayed as revenge for his forcing her to marry him, but eventually it amounts to the same thing. She doesn't truly punish Zeus who cares little for the women he sleeps with and instead torments the people he victimizes as well as their children in some instances. She lacks the insight to see how her actions affect anyone outside of herself and becomes blinded by her own rage. It felt like a huge fumble in the handling of her character.
Additionally, this book suffered from being overlong. I get that Hera has a massive presence within mythology, but I felt like Saint was summarizing everything she ever did and it made the book tedious in the middle. I think it would've been better served had she focused on 3-5 integral moments and delved more into depth with how they were important to Hera's story. I didn't need to watch her exact revenge on every nymph, mortal, and Demi-god that slept with Zeus.
That said, it wasn't all bad. This book shines when it talks about Hera's relationship with Echidna and her monster children. I loved the parallels drawn between the two of them despite their massive differences. It's one of the few points in the book that Hera actually express any level of compassion or empathy as well. It had the affect of making her feel less flat which is something sorely needed within this narrative.
I also thought that Hera's relationship with Athena was handled well. They aren't friends, but there is a begrudging respect between the two of them and they ally with each other when convenient to their motivations. Unfortunately, I actually felt Athena outshined Hera in the book which is frustrating since Hera is the titular character.
Naomi Frederick narrates the audiobook and is possibly the best part of it. Her voice really brings the characters to life, telling the story in an easy to follow way. I always listen to audiobooks at 2-3x speed, so I appreciated that her narration still sounded good sped up.
All in all, I wanted much more from this book. It felt more like the spark notes summary of Hera as told by Greek mythology instead of a new, fresh take. I don't know if Saint is under an inordinate amount of pressure to turn out a new retelling every year, but I think slowing down her publishing rate and taking the time to really challenge the traditional portrayals of her characters might result in a better book. Clearly, she is a talented writer and well-versed in mythology and I wish she was given time for that talent to shine.
*Thank you to Netgalley, Flatiron Books, and Jennifer Saint for the ARC. This in no way affects the objectivity of my review.
Moderate: Confinement, Emotional abuse, Misogyny, Rape, Sexual assault, Toxic relationship, Violence, and War