At one point I thought this was gonna be a 4 or 5 stars, but as time passes I don't like it more and more.
The present timeline wasn't as enjoyable for me as the past. The past timeline just had more intrigue, I needed to know what actually happened. I wish we had more scenes with the other 2 girls from the past so that the ending would have a bigger impact. There was minimal interaction with the FMC so it was hard to care for them. Also, there was some weird mental health rep that never really got fully explained or got deeper explored and I didn't like how it was used. While I can appreciate rep where it doesn't have to be all about it, but rather just a thing a character lives with, I feel like it was impacting the storyline enough to require more exploration than we got. 

This is my second 3 star book from Riley Sager, and both have been from his backlist which many people prefer over his newer works so I think he isn't an author for me.