I enjoyed the book, I particularly liked how the mixed religion and witchcraft (which a lot of people probably won't/didn't). But I thought it made sense, since I do not think of religion as black and white as they indoctrinate us in catechism school. I would say it was a beatiful love story in the end but I would have wanted more. All in all is not a book for everyone, especially if you are not willing to keep an open mind.