I wanted this book to be a 5 star read, and while all the ingredients were there, it just didn’t add up.  Definitely an impressive debut novel, and while I didn’t notice any major plot holes, I didn’t fall in love with the story or the characters. The character progression was solid, the setting was unique and well-rounded, and the plot was well-paced. I loved Marcellus’s chapters and wish more was told through his POV.  It’s hard for me to pin point where this fell short, but I’m still glad I read it!