Jill Baguchinsky delivers a compelling feminist queer horror novel that carves its own unique path in So Witches We Became. While it shares some atmospheric similarities with The Mist, the story stands strong on its own, blending suspense, mystery, and empowerment into a page-turning tale. 

Baguchinsky’s writing is skillful and vivid, painting the eerie setting and spine-chilling moments with precision. The island’s haunting atmosphere and the chilling mystery of its supposed curse kept me guessing, and the sense of satisfaction when the title’s meaning became clear was a standout moment. 

Though the novel leans toward the spooky rather than full-on horror, it strikes a perfect balance for young adult readers. The fright factor is just enough to keep the story edgy without crossing into overwhelming territory. Baguchinsky also weaves in thoughtful flashbacks that offer valuable insight into the characters, enriching the narrative and creating deeper emotional resonance. 

This is a story that thrives on suspense and intrigue, drawing readers in with its mysterious twists and turns. It’s an excellent choice for fans of YA horror looking for something a little spooky but not overly intense. However, I strongly recommend checking the trigger warnings, as some elements may be unsettling for sensitive readers. 

If you enjoy eerie tales filled with empowerment, mystery, and a dash of fright, So Witches We Became is a book you won’t want to miss.