A review by dlwaugh
Cynical Theories: How Activist Scholarship Made Everything about Race, Gender, and Identity — And Why This Harms Everybody by Helen Pluckrose, James Lindsay

4.0

The book is a very helpful dive into critical theories with chapters on postcolonnial theory, queer theory, critical race theory, feminism and gender studies, and disability and fat studies. The authors tie all these theories to the broader postmodern theory and its "applied turn" which is helpful. One of the most problematic aspects all these theories share is that they are un-criticisable (I made that word up). Critique is simply oppression by another name.

I believe that, at points, the authors were picking the most extreme papers and case studies to make their point, which made the alarmist a bit less credible. In addition, I'm probably more open to accepting some aspects of postmodern philosophy than the authors are, which leads me to be more open to some of the insights from these critical theories. I'm glad I read a bit of Richard Delgado (critical race theorist) before reading this - it helped me understand that particular movement and then the critique a bit better.

The book helped me understand that words/phrases I use may not mean the same thing to everyone, especially those steeped in the academic world (i.e. systemic racism, social justice, etc)

In the end, I do believe these critical theories are counterproductive and will only serve to exacerbate problems related to racism, sexism, bigotry towards LGBTQ persons, etc.