A review by lisaluvsliterature
Under the Surface by Diana Urban

adventurous dark emotional informative mysterious reflective sad tense medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.25

This is an author I’ve wanted to read for a while, so I was excited when I won an ARC from Bookish First. It seemed appropriate that I picked it up to read when the Olympics were in Paris as well!
Most of the story is from Ruby’s viewpoint, as she goes to Paris on a school field trip. Of course she is a travel blogger/influencer, and really wants to see certain things that are unusual. One of those things is the catacombs. Also on the trip is her ex-best friend and her current best friend. Her current best friend, Val, is a bit of a wild child. In fact she sneaks out the first night there to go to a party with a cute guy she met on their daily outing. When Ruby finds out, she tries to stop her. But sneaking out she gets caught by her ex-best friend, as well as another of their friends. Those two girls end up sneaking with her so they don’t get caught either. When they catch up with Val and this guy, he is already getting ready to take them down a manhole to a secret entrance that isn’t open to the public. He says he is going to a party with other “cataphiles” people who like exploring the catacombs. 
Of course once they get down there, things just don’t go right. Julien, the guy, won’t let her take pictures for her travel blog because people can’t know how the cataphiles get down there or they might get caught and those ways blocked off. Of course some get hurt. They get lost. It floods when it rains, and then there seem to be people chasing them, dressed in skeleton costumes, scary skeleton costumes. Through their traversing for over 3 days, they come to know each other. Secrets and lies that had come between Ruby and her best friend Selena come out. Ruby also learns that maybe Val isn’t as good a friend as she says she is. 
We also get a bit of the story from Sean’s viewpoint. Sean is another of Ruby’s closest friends. In fact she thinks she likes him as more than a friend, and that maybe he feels the same way. But he will be going away after high school where she won’t see him all the time, and she’s not able to deal with people leaving her, like her mom, and her friend, etc. Sean also is interested in Ruby. And he wants her to know. He also doesn’t trust Val, after she did something that we find out about in the story with the ones lost in the catacombs. And when the girls disappear, he makes it his mission to do whatever he can to help them get out, as well as be there for her when she makes it out. In doing all this, he also takes steps to let his father know what he really wants to do with his life, and starts to figure that out a bit as well.
There are a lot of tense moments as we follow the girls through the tunnels with their mysterious French cataphile tour guide Julien. And lots of moments of waiting, as Sean and the other teachers, students and French police try to find them. Definitely was a good story, and will have it available for my students to read!