I always enjoy a Sophie Winston mystery and was excited that all of my favorite side characters made an appearance. However, after 15 books, the plots are bound to get more complicated to fool Sophie (and the reader). I had a hard time following some of Sophie’s logical leaps, often ending up at a different person than she did. I also suspected the murderer (though without the details of how) before Sophie figured it out. However, despite a few gaps in the plot, I enjoyed spending time with the whole Old Town gang, and the mystery was still satisfying.