This book is an emotional roller coaster. It was so good though. I feel so bad for Skyclan, they don't deserve any of the bad things that happened to them in this book.

TBH Hawkwing's romance was so random like he just suddenly decided that he no longer couldn't stand Pebbleshine and loved her instead. The Erins should also emphasize age for these characters cuz Hawkwing fell in love with Pebbleshine when she was still an apprentice and I get that like they are close in age and it's not weird but it's walking a fine line cuz we don't know for sure if she is full-grown when he starts looking at her in a romantic way. It could have been written better.