3.75 stars
ryle, i loved u but u broke all of our hearts. colleen wrote him in the most realistic and perfect way. he was beautiful and terrible and unforgivable all at once.

atlas, i cant wait to see more of him. his protection, his calm aura, his support, his love. i was so grateful on behalf of lily that she had him there.

lily, her mistakes were so realistic and hit close to home. so proud of her decisions and can’t imagine how hard it would have been.

my first ever colleen hoover book and i was not disappointed. my heart is aching. somehow the acknowledgements made me cry even more.

update: 3 stars. the more this sits with me the less i love it. definitely still like it though and recommend