The Heart in Winter by Kevin Barry is a frustrating exercise in literary excess. Unlike Cormac McCarthy, who masters the art of sparse yet powerful prose, Barry's writing feels indulgent, repetitive, and overwritten. The novel is bogged down by flroid language and overuse of archaic words, turning what could be succinct storytelling into a drawn-out, tedious read. Barry's self-indulgence is palpable - his thesaurus is clearly well-worn.

The characters, intended to be gritty and authentic, instead come across as half-baked, like rejects from Deadwood. They lack depth and fail to convince, leaving the reader disconnected from their fates. The emotional range is monotonous, leaning too heavily on a stereotypical portrayal of Irish melancholy, all bawling and brawling with little else to offer.

For a book that should have been a quick read, The Heart in Winter is surprisingly hard to follow and, frankly, a chore to finish. Barry misses the mark here, delivering a novel that feels more like a pretentious exercise than a compelling narrative.

⭐