This one was lackluster for me. The premise sounded promising enough — an unconventional woman, childhood friends separated by an unexpected peerage sounded interesting, second chance, etc. However, these elements and the overall execution never really came together and bordered on boring at times. The story also felt very modern, yanking me out of the narrative a few times to regain my bearings. 

Phoebe seemed to martyr herself and quickly became one of the least interesting characters. The Duke came off as flat and a milksop who hesitated to assert his own opinions or thoughts. Instead, it seems like Phoebe will ultimately be responsible for acting as both their spines. 

Several plot lines (e.g., the Annie mystery) were resolved unceremoniously in ways that didn't fit the build-up. Others were disappointing, such as Will's repeated insistence that Phoebe isn't fit to be a duchess, just to be resolved by her apology. 

Overall, Duchess Material was fine, with a passable happy ending. While I didn't love this one, I would read a follow-up centered on one of Phoebe's sisters.

✨2.5 — rounded to 3 for review purposes

Thanks to the author, NetGalley and Forever for the advance copy in exchange for my review.