I liked how this started off and as a fan of insta-love I really wish the author would have just leaned all the way into the trope and the concept of a character obsessed with pumpkin spice. Like the missed opportunity to make all their dates pumpkin spice related, him being a coffee shop owner he could have been making her new drinks to try daily. I also didn’t love the subplot and the direction it went. But mostly I just wished that everything after the conversation with his sister wasn’t so vague and unfortunately boring.