I really enjoyed this book! I’m giving it 5 stars because I just don’t think 4 stars is enough. It may not be the best book ever but it was perfect for Halloween/ fall. I loved vivi Gwynn and Elaine. Rhys annoyed me at times but he definitely grew on me. I think this had the perfect mix of magic and romance with a few very well written spicy scenes! I highly recommend to read around Halloween.