This is a well written book that I probably should not have picked up or continued reading. Turns out it wasn’t for me. A few public readers and podcast hosts whose taste I like said they really liked it so I bought it. As this group of Unitarian Universalists search for a new leader at their church we are along for the ride and quickly realize that the committee members each have their own personal searches.

Early on it is made very clear (several times) that this is not a Christian church, like I expected from the descriptions I heard. “But I keep waiting to hear, you know, about God, and Jesus, and what we’re supposed to believe in.” And later it says “We don’t push any dogma, doctrine, or creed. It’s even fine that you’re a Trinitarian.” Still, I chose to keep reading. 

Michelle Huneven is gifted at writing diverse people and each character’s dialogue and attributes were identifiable. I was never confused as to who was talking. I’ve been on a search committee and much of it was relatable. I liked the premise and the way recipes were incorporated. I didn’t like the characters disdain for Christians. I did like how the book ended. 

I think this book will be enjoyable for some but it wasn’t the right book for me. 

“You don’t realize how thirsty you are for such full attention until it comes to you. One by one, we bloomed under her gaze.”

“… in my experience, the people who join search committees are often seeking a change for themselves – the internal self is conducting its own search alongside the church’s.“