The good: 

You guys know how much I love it when each POV in an audiobook gets their own narrator, so I enjoyed that aspect quite a bit. 

The book was short and really readable, definitely something that was quick to get through with a bit of a mystery and family drama.  Overall, it was fun, I finished it quickly, and definitely enjoyed the story at first. 

The not so good:

Predictable. The narrators also didn’t help with this because I was really suspicious of one person and I feel like the particular narrator just gave me vibes like they knew from the beginning they should be suspicious sounding. 

The throwback details. I said this in my buddy reads group that the 90s details were all so wrong, I didn’t need to look up the age of the author to know she wasn’t quite a teen/older kid in 1999. Things like Red Solo cups weren’t called that or popular until at least 2004. By the end of the 90s even the lower middle class families replaced their giant 80s camcorders with compact ones. 

I think younger readers would totally fly past all of it and not care, but there were so many details that were off by a few years and just weren’t right. 

Unrelated to the throwback stuff, it also really bothered me that a bank representative would allow someone access to anything without a valid ID just because they were upset. I hated getting pulled out of the story for details that were just so wrong in real life. 

Overall, I enjoyed the story, but there were too many holes and things that bothered me to rate it any higher.