(Actual: 4.75⭐️, rounded up) I’ll admit, I wasn’t too sure about this novel at first bc the title sounded so….. plain to me?? Sorry lol. BUT— what a wonderful surprise it turned out to be! My first real holiday-centric book & it seriously had no right being as cute as it is. I’m not even a ~grinch~ about the holidays like our FMC, Molly, is and yet this book thawed my apparently actually frozen heart