it was an okay book, but not really what I was expecting or what I particularly was in the mood to read.
I loved the writing style and I will happily read McGarry again.
I wasn't too keen on the focus of Echo's torment with her mother. I felt the true answer was very implausible and didn't fit with the scaring. there were also things left unfinished like the scar in her back she only showed Noah? What was it?
I like the characters and their individuality.

Overall this gets 3.5 stars because of how much focus was directed at Echo's story which was heavily flawed.