I actually really enjoyed this book. It was a nice break from what I have been reading. I loved the drama and relationships evolving. And surprisingly, I loved Alex. Usually when authors introduce new characters for the group I can't stand it. This time it works because I still feel like they are not totally established as a group yet. Honestly I made it 4 stars because it was irritating how perfect Charlotte seemed sometimes and the repetitive use of adorable and cute as descriptors for her got super old