A review by natashaleighton_
Tales of a Monstrous Heart by Jennifer Delaney

adventurous dark emotional mysterious tense medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

5.0

A decadently rich, slow burn fantasy that completely stole my heart! 

As a huge fan of Jane Eyre (it’s been my favourite classic since I was twelve), I knew I needed to check out Tales of A Monstrous Heart as soon as I heard it took inspiration from it. And I’m soo glad I did, as I absolutely loved every vividly atmospheric second.

From the themes of class and discrimination, the gorgeously gothic setting and our phenomenally resilient and determined protagonist, Katherine— as well as our mysteriously brooding Lord Blackthorn. The glimmers of what made Brontë’s novel soo successful were wonderfully present (and really felt like a love letter to Brontë.)

But it’s Jennifer Delaney’s ability to craft such a complex and wholly unique tale, without losing any of the essence (and emotional complexity) that encompassed Brontë’s original— that really blew me away. 

Part gothic fantasy, part social commentary on real world issues, such as: the discrimination and oppression of marginalised groups, identity, class, systemic inequality and even the corruption of power. Delaney effortlessly explores it all, weaving magic and fae based lore with her own evocative insights that bring her compelling (and rather introspective) characters to life. 

I adored Katherine, who was such a loveably engaging character, and whose defiance of the social norms (and the very discriminatory expectations placed upon her) had me utterly transfixed. 

Lord Emerys Blackthorn was just as intriguing and I loved the intensity of the slow-burn relationship that blossoms between him and Katherine. Their interactions were brimming with longing that led to satisfying (and emotionally charged) payoff that was soo worth the wait. 

There’s nothing else I can really add that all the glowing reviews haven’t already covered. So I’ll just say, if you love gothic fantasy, the Brontë sisters or even Carnival Row (the Cara Delevingne & Orlando Bloom led show) then you should definitely consider picking this up ASAP! 

Though I do recommend checking TWs beforehand.

Expand filter menu Content Warnings