4.5 rounded up.

While I did enjoy this rendition of the story from Edward's perspective, I now think I need to read this again immediately after finishing Bella's perspective so I can compare the feel of the stories.

The way Edward is a lil creepy stalked boy and watches her through other peoples thoughts since he can't read her at all is something. Should have expected it but was unprepared.

Overall, I liked getting his side, but the internal monologue he had a was lil meh (very on character). The fact Charlie has ~no thoughts~ killed me.