A review by kassielovestoread
Water Moon by Samantha Sotto Yambao

adventurous emotional mysterious reflective slow-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.75

Water Moon was a riveting story whose plot was equally engaging as the world building/magic system. Every single page of this novel was uniquely described; you can tell a lot of care and attention went into every detail featured. Just when you think the world couldn't be more magical or special, the author introduces another layer to dissect and marvel at. This glittering world is both beautiful and alluring, but beneath the surface lies a sinister truth that is closely guarded by the cruel and mysterious forces of the Shiikuin. Enter Keishein; a prospective client or something more? His appearance on the worst day of Hana's life is an unknown factor that completely changes the trajectory of the story. Trust me when I say that when the truth is finally revealed, it will leave your jaw hanging. 

Everyone who equated this story to a Studio Ghibli film was absolutely correct. The author paints such vivid scenes in your head, it felt like watching a movie the entire time. I adored the romance between Keishen and Hana; I rooted for them the entire time. I underlined way too much in this book and it's all the author's fault for writing such memorable and impactful scenes, lol. Similarly to Studio Ghibli films, this book also packs an emotional punch. I felt the tightness in my throat trying (and eventually failing) to hold back tears as this book reached its conclusion.

I think on the surface one could describe this as a cozy fantasy. I can see why, but I'd ultimately challenge that assertion. While the magic is certainly dream-like and incredibly whimsical, this book touches on a lot of themes that cut to the quick. Parental abandonment, parental death, depression, feelings of unworthiness/alienation, grief, regret...etc. Not to mention that the stakes in this book are quite high; Keishein and Hana are quite literally running for their lives trying to save her father. There are tender moments aplenty in this novel, but they are brief moments that the characters have while fighting for their lives. All this to say that I, of course, recommend this book; I just wanted to share my thoughts on the genre classification. 

Finally, I will say that there were a few things that stopped this from being a perfect 5 star read. Some of the scenes were transitioned abruptly and therefore came across as awkward. Sometimes the scenes would end on a really interesting conversation and I know that it breaks because obviously it's over, but too many times I wanted to see how it would play out! In addition, I think some of the biggest reveals in this book were stated a little too bluntly. The impact was not as great as it could've been if it were delivered a little better.