The basics were ok, though nobody who reads mysteries was even vaguely fooled by the "locked room mystery." It's months after the last one, and Marc's back in town with a partner who thinks Addie must be guilty because she used to date mark. Very annoying. Marc claiming they're just following leads is nonsense, as Addie points out, yet they don't widen their search. That also leads to why this is three-stars rather than four. At the end, Addie is willing to talk to them and any intelligent person wouldn't be after the way they treated her. Also, folks in Seattle rarely use umbrellas, it's a light rain.