Scan barcode
A review by sharkybookshelf
And Then There Were None by Agatha Christie
5.0
Ten strangers are invited to an island mansion by its mysterious owner where, on their first evening, they are each accused of a crime - with no way of leaving the island, they find themselves picked off one-by-one…
This is the first Christie I ever read back when I was 12 or 13, and over 20 years later, I still remember feeling completely mind-blown. It’s the book that kick-started my love for Christie’s mysteries and was my firm favourite going into my Sharky Reads Christie project, so I was actually a little nervous about picking it up - it had a lot to live up to…
Anyway, I’m happy to report that it did stand up to the heavy weight of my expectations - it’s a Christie classic for a reason. Enduringly clever, and even though I’ve read it before several times (but couldn’t quite remember the solution), I did not figure it out. My only minor criticism is that explaining the solution via epilogue feels slightly clumsy, but I also don’t know how else Christie could have done it - bringing detectives in and having them going over everything would rapidly become repetitive in a format that already runs the risk of feeling repetitive (but doesn’t).
There is an excellent Author’s Note (swipe to read), and I agree with Christie - she had every right to be pleased with herself for pulling off such a difficult premise. It is a book to pit your brain against, not one to read for character development. It’s a puzzle, pure and simple, and that’s what I truly love about Christie’s mysteries.
Would I say it’s still my favourite Christie? Well, I’m not sure I can pick a hands-down favourite actually, but a joint-favourite, certainly - it just has to share the top spot with The Murder of Roger Ackroyd and Murder in Mesopotamia.
The ultimate locked room murder mystery, ingenious yet elegantly simple without being obvious.