In this historical reference, author Summers, tells the story Husband Kimmel, the Admiral in charge of the Pacific Fleet during the Pearl Harbor attack. As a hobbyist WWII historian, it has always been intriguing how ADM Kimmel was dealt with in the aftermath. The research and information that I had studied suggested that maybe he wasn't as much at fault as history leads us to believe.

This book does an excellent job of bringing all of the material together to give the best picture of what actually took place. Ultimately, Kimmel was the man in charge and was responsible but there was a lot of extenuating circumstances that stacked the deck for success against him. For example, the compartmentalization in Washington kept key intelligence data from Kimmel. Had he known that the Japanese had studied a successful harbor bombing, in shallow water with aerial torpedos in Italy, he might of changed his strategy. When he requested torpedo nets for the entrances to the harbor, it was declined. He asked for more airplanes to cover reconnaissance and routine patrols but was denied. This led to a poorly informed Commander who could only act on with the data and resources provided.

Once Pearl Harbor was attacked, ADM Kimmel was promptly fired and sent back to the U.S. in utter disgrace. During the hearings afterwards, there was a significant amount of politicians that looked to obfuscate and protect their own careers. In the end, ADM Kimmel was reduced in rank to Rear Admiral and left the Navy. He and later, his family, have continued to try and clear his name. It is truly a matter of honor.

I finished this book! Took me a couple of weeks but I did. And I really rather enjoyed it, which is perhaps inappropriate given the subject matter, but whatever. It was a good read. I learned some stuff, which is always nice.

In "A Matter of Honor: Pearl Harbor: Betrayal, Blame, and a Family's Quest for Justice" Anthony Summers has written what is likely to be the definitive account of the events that led to the Pearl Harbor attack (on the U.S. Pacific Fleet) of December 7th, 1941 and the failures among the U.S. political and military leadership that helped make the attack likely.

Summers has a deserved reputation as a journalist/writer who leaves no stone unturned and scrupulously explores every source available to him, checking thoroughly for the veracity of various documents and data he finds on a subject that is his prime interest. Some years ago, I read his biography of J. Edgar Hoover - 'Official and Confidential, The Secret Life of J. Edgar Hoover' - which made me a fervent fan of his work. (The way he was able to marshal facts and personal accounts from people who both worked closely for Hoover or suffered as the result of his unjust acts, absolutely captivated my interest in the book.) And here in "A Matter of Honor", as a way of giving a further scope to the common narrative of the Pearl Harbor attack that has been perpetuated for decades, Summer provides the reader with a compelling account of the life and career of Admiral Husband E. Kimmel - the commander of the Pacific Fleet at Pearl Harbor. Here was a man who devoted his whole life to the U.S. Navy, from his time at Annapolis in the early 1900s, to the various commands he served - always earning the highest commendations from his superiors. He truly epitomized through his personal conduct and service all that could be asked for from an officer.

Yet, from the time, Kimmel was made commander of the U.S. Pacific Fleet in February 1941, there are factors that Summers brings to light that show that Kimmel and his Army counterpart, General Walter Short, were not provided with all the resources they needed to defend Hawaii against a possible Japanese attack. This was during a time when diplomatic relations between the U.S. and Japan were deteriorating, and by the latter part of 1941, it was judged likely by both Washington and the top military leadership that war between the 2 countries would result. (Indeed, the U.S. military had broken the Japanese military and diplomatic codes - and so, had some sense of what Tokyo was contemplating as a resolution to its impasse with Washington.)

This is a book that anyone who wants to know the definitive account of who(m) is (are) responsible or culpable for the tragedy of Pearl Harbor should read and then quietly reflect upon. I know that I will never again judge Admiral Husband Kimmel as guilty as dereliction of duty. In my view, he was a convenient scapegoat (which is not easy for me to admit, as someone who had earlier accepted wholesale the official stories behind Admiral Kimmel's and General Short's "neglect" of Hawaii's defense).

In this historical reference, author Summers, tells the story Husband Kimmel, the Admiral in charge of the Pacific Fleet during the Pearl Harbor attack. As a hobbyist WWII historian, it has always been intriguing how ADM Kimmel was dealt with in the aftermath. The research and information that I had studied suggested that maybe he wasn't as much at fault as history leads us to believe.

This book does an excellent job of bringing all of the material together to give the best picture of what actually took place. Ultimately, Kimmel was the man in charge and was responsible but there was a lot of extenuating circumstances that stacked the deck for success against him. For example, the compartmentalization in Washington kept key intelligence data from Kimmel. Had he known that the Japanese had studied a successful harbor bombing, in shallow water with aerial torpedos in Italy, he might of changed his strategy. When he requested torpedo nets for the entrances to the harbor, it was declined. He asked for more airplanes to cover reconnaissance and routine patrols but was denied. This led to a poorly informed Commander who could only act on with the data and resources provided.

Once Pearl Harbor was attacked, ADM Kimmel was promptly fired and sent back to the U.S. in utter disgrace. During the hearings afterwards, there was a significant amount of politicians that looked to obfuscate and protect their own careers. In the end, ADM Kimmel was reduced in rank to Rear Admiral and left the Navy. He and later, his family, have continued to try and clear his name. It is truly a matter of honor.