Reviews

The Firemaker by Peter May

gaila's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

The story in itself wasn't that bad - a good thriller to keep you occupied for an afternoon or so, even though I guessed all the details of the climax about 100 pages before any of the main characters.

But MY GOD why is the author so obsessed with us knowing that his main female character isn't EVER wearing a bra ?? First of all, it's unrealistic and unprofessional as FUCK, second of all, has he ever met an actual woman? I'm seriously starting to doubt it.

dhmd's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous mysterious tense fast-paced

4.0

janhutch's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

A great start to a new series (to me) by Peter May. This one takes place in China, and of course, the inevitable culture clash that occurs when North America meets China. In this case, it’s over an autopsy table. Good read.

shawn27's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

It started out as a decent police procedural, set in China. The formula is overdone, but the characters are decent. However, the book somehow morphed into a Michael Crichton end-of-the-world thriller in the last chapters. This is one of the first books by the author, and there is a substantial body of work to read now. I'm hoping that in his later works he stuck to what he was good at, and left the rest behind.

glou's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Different than other May books but very Good!

saspist's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

20 year old book is well plotted intriguing thriller. Flawed and very different heroes are from America and China.

carolefort's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

The Firemaker by Peter May reminds me why this author is so well-reviewed and a star in his field. This novel is the first of seven in the China Thrillers series and it will be a pleasure to read each one. Margaret Campbell is a forensic pathologist from Chicago who has been invited to Beijing to lecture for six weeks at the police university. She has left much emotional baggage back home and hopes that China will be a distraction. And a distraction it surely is. An accidental and abrupt meeting with senior detective Li Yan does not bode well and the pair are off to an unfriendly start. But their relationship changes when the pair find themselves investigating three murders together. This police procedural introduces readers to Chinese laws and investigations practices. I admit that I knew very little about life in China and The Firemaker has been quite an eye-opener. Peter May has done years of research into this subject and it shows on every page. This novel is a satisfying murder mystery and a close look underneath the surface of life in China in the present and also in the past. And the whole book is wrapped up with a shocking ending and a very effective cliffhanger to entice the reader to read the entire series. Highly recommended.

chattycathy55's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

to much romance in the book. i did like the china history and the main protagonists are interesting if there was not so much goofy romance. the storyline was interesting.

mic_vic's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

I got eight percent of the way into this book. TBH, I thought I did pretty well to get that far.

If you want soap opera melodrama obviousness in a book, you will love this.

If you've read May's Lewis Men trilogy, don't sully the memory by going anywhere near this egregious garbage.

muyelinh's review against another edition

Go to review page

dark emotional informative mysterious tense slow-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? It's complicated
  • Diverse cast of characters? No
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

3.0

Die "China Thrillers" des schottischen Autoren Peter May sind nur teilweise (die ersten drei Teile) ins Deutsche übertragen worden. Dennoch eilt ihnen ein vergleichsweise guter Ruf voraus, wenn man bedenkt, dass Teil 2 über einen Bücherschrank zu mir gefunden hat. 
Nun also der Eröffnungsband: Natürlich fokussiert sich die Darstellung besonders auf unsere beiden Hauptfiguren, den Kommissar Li Yan und die amerikanische Pathologin Margaret Campbell, die eher zufällig in ihr China-Abenteuer gestolpert ist. Daneben geht es viel um die Atmosphäre der ätzend heißen und trubeligen Weltstadt Beijing - und um den unausweichlichen Culture Clash der Protagonisten. Allerhand skurriles kommt in diesem wilden Sammelsurium zusammen, sodass der eigentliche Kriminalfall - drei Opfer schwerer Verbrennungen, die erstmal nicht viel gemeinsam haben, erstmal eher in den Hintergrund rückt. 

May schreibt sehr zugänglich und schafft eine passende Mischung aus Humor und Emotionalität. Wenngleich die Komposition seines Verbrechens spannende Ansätze erkennen lässt, bleibt der Plot eher blass und ein wenig träge, insbesondere als dann auch eine allzu omnipräsente romantische Komponente hinzukommt. 

Der Fall läuft schlussendlich auf eine weltumspannende Verschwörung zu und realisiert sich in durchaus einschneidenden Konsequenzen, machte es mir aber vor allem im Mittelteil nicht gerade einfach, dranzubleiben. 

Potenzial war da, ich hoffe, dass dieses im nächsten Band noch etwas stärker gehoben wird.