Scan barcode
sakurablossom87's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
dark
emotional
funny
inspiring
mysterious
reflective
sad
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
devannm's review
3.0
I thought reading the manga would help me focus on the plot more but there is just something about this series that makes my eyes unfocus when I try to pay attention to what's going on even though I do adore the main characters [honestly that's the only reason I'm even making the effort]. This volume is pretty much just more of the same, although there's a nice extended fight scene and they've also introduced a hermaphrodite character [is that even acceptable terminology anymore? or is it just intersex?] which, in what I can only assume from my experience with other late 90s / early 2000s shounen anime/manga series, is almost certainly going to be a super unfortunate attempt to be ~edgy~. I'm pretty they just made them a girl in the show although it's been ages since I watched it so maybe I'm not remembering right, but anyway I'm sure that'll be a whole thing although I'm trying to reserve judgement for now.
tixdixl's review
adventurous
dark
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
Moderate: Sexual assault and Sexual harassment
Nuditytheseventhl's review
3.0
Yet another case of a 3.5 rather than a 3 star volume - but it's getting there, slowly but surely, to the 4 star mark. A lot of backstory for Sanzo in this volume, as well as a lot of team bonding and many hints of Hakkai's past that can only mean the next volume will be very Hakkai heavy.
The series seems to have taken a huge stepback from the 'yokai issue of the week' which had defined its first two volumes, which is probably for a better because there is only so much after school special lessons on yokai & human relations I can take before begging for some actual plot development. Mercifully, there is some, including actual fleshed-out scenes involing Kougaiji and the people he works with.
However, this volume unfortunately undercuts the serious lack of interesting female characters in the series so far; either women are inherently helpless and require the Sanzo gang's assistance, are 'evil' in the sense that they are working for the revival of Gyumaoh, or are both (see: Yaone in volume 2). The most important female figure so far in the series - Kougaiji's mother - is literally unable to move or speak or participate in the action. None of them are sensibly fleshed out so far, not even in comparison to the tons of story we've been getting about Sanzo and the gang. But of course, why introduce complex interesting female people that might distract from all the sexy young men running about with their quest and amazing physical abilities?
One might also question why the only yokai characters are either evil, berserk, or Sanzo's cohorts, but I'm pretty sure this issue is addressed in later volumes. Still, the portrayal of post-Minus Wave yokai as being all mindless violent killing machines and the ones who aren't being part human and on a mission from god is problematic to say the least. I think the odds of Sanzo getting a full-blooded yokai ally grows smaller and smaller with every passing chapter.
Well, at least the art is getting better, right? Right? Eh.
The series seems to have taken a huge stepback from the 'yokai issue of the week' which had defined its first two volumes, which is probably for a better because there is only so much after school special lessons on yokai & human relations I can take before begging for some actual plot development. Mercifully, there is some, including actual fleshed-out scenes involing Kougaiji and the people he works with.
However, this volume unfortunately undercuts the serious lack of interesting female characters in the series so far; either women are inherently helpless and require the Sanzo gang's assistance, are 'evil' in the sense that they are working for the revival of Gyumaoh, or are both (see: Yaone in volume 2). The most important female figure so far in the series - Kougaiji's mother - is literally unable to move or speak or participate in the action. None of them are sensibly fleshed out so far, not even in comparison to the tons of story we've been getting about Sanzo and the gang. But of course, why introduce complex interesting female people that might distract from all the sexy young men running about with their quest and amazing physical abilities?
One might also question why the only yokai characters are either evil, berserk, or Sanzo's cohorts, but I'm pretty sure this issue is addressed in later volumes. Still, the portrayal of post-Minus Wave yokai as being all mindless violent killing machines and the ones who aren't being part human and on a mission from god is problematic to say the least. I think the odds of Sanzo getting a full-blooded yokai ally grows smaller and smaller with every passing chapter.
Well, at least the art is getting better, right? Right? Eh.
siria's review
3.0
I loved the interaction of the characters in all of this - the ways in which Minekura has Sanzo, Hakkai, Goku and Gojyo play off against each other, and also in the ways in which the opposing Sanzo and Kougaiji teas play against each other. All four of the main protagonists have such interesting backgrounds, and I really admire the ways in which Minekura is revealing them.
I'm finding the layout much easier to follow, even though there are still times when I find my eyes wandering from left-to-right, and even more times when I find the action scenes confusing. I really have to slow down and take my time reading these volumes at the moment; I think, though, that as I progress, my speed will improve.
I'm finding the layout much easier to follow, even though there are still times when I find my eyes wandering from left-to-right, and even more times when I find the action scenes confusing. I really have to slow down and take my time reading these volumes at the moment; I think, though, that as I progress, my speed will improve.
brookeisbusyreading's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
reflective
tense
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
Aw, man! This is one of those volumes where every page/scene/panel is so wonderfully designed! There’s so much action - which I expected having seen the anime - I kept pausing to admire the art style and dedication I know went into all of the characters and details!
After Vol. 2 left me on a cliffhanger, I had to get to this one! Goku and Sanzo’s relationship is just awesome! I love how it doesn’t come across as a older man/teenage boy romance type of relationship but rather a mentor/guardian to student/brat relationship. Throw in what little of their tragic backstories we’ve seen so far, and I can feel how strong of a bond those two have. One of the things I love about Saiyuki is how it handles relationships, particularly with ‘saying things without saying them’. This goes along with Gojyo and Hakkai’s relationship, though more as a brotherly bond.
The end of the Rikudo arc is intense and I love that the Chin Yisou is next because it deals with some heavy stuff - important backstory for Hakkai that explains his demon origin. I would say the Rikudo arc should also be an example of what happens to Sanzo for the rest of the story lol
Another incredible volume and I’m reminded again of just how much I love this series!
After Vol. 2 left me on a cliffhanger, I had to get to this one! Goku and Sanzo’s relationship is just awesome! I love how it doesn’t come across as a older man/teenage boy romance type of relationship but rather a mentor/guardian to student/brat relationship. Throw in what little of their tragic backstories we’ve seen so far, and I can feel how strong of a bond those two have. One of the things I love about Saiyuki is how it handles relationships, particularly with ‘saying things without saying them’. This goes along with Gojyo and Hakkai’s relationship, though more as a brotherly bond.
The end of the Rikudo arc is intense and I love that the Chin Yisou is next because it deals with some heavy stuff - important backstory for Hakkai that explains his demon origin. I would say the Rikudo arc should also be an example of what happens to Sanzo for the rest of the story lol
Another incredible volume and I’m reminded again of just how much I love this series!
anshin's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
emotional
funny
tense
fast-paced
5.0
flowhella's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
funny
fast-paced
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.5