4.25 AVERAGE

challenging dark emotional sad tense medium-paced

A book like this is hard to review, but I think it is an important book and worth the time and energy to read.

Having previously read Footnotes in Gaza, I eagerly delved into Palestine. Originally published as a nine-issue comic series and collected in a two-volume collection, Sacco's eyewitness account of the Occupied Territories as the first Intifada was losing steam (1991-1992) is visually and emotionally stunning.

Sacco puts himself in the story- showing his irritation with endless cups of sugary tea, relating his seemingly heartless journalistic desire to have heard more about the injured and seen the graphic photos that deeply upset his photographer Saburo, and shaking like a leaf when he witnesses a demonstration and clash that is just one of many for residents of Ramallah. With the tone he takes--a play on his ambitions in the first chapter ('mission accomplished')--he displays for readers his own ignorance, Western attitudes, and naivete to let the images and stories stand in contrast to any glib, simplistic, or reductive lines of thought.

Some tales spread over several pages. Some are featured as a two page spread, a vivid snapshot. In all cases, Sacco uses the graphic novel form to good effect. 'Moderate Pressure Part II', for example, uses small squares of images in a grid to illustrate confines, repetition, the seemingly endless hours of sleep deprivation, and being tied, hooded, in uncomfortable positions. The frame around the images only expands when the imprisoned man is set free.

The enormity of injustice and suffering is overwhelming. 'That's that! A speedy interview! An entire tragedy in under 20 minutes...' (p.246)
emotional informative reflective fast-paced

This is the first political book that I might have actually learned something from. Or rather, this is the first middle east conflict book that didn't seem confusing and pointless. I'm not sure about the ending, it seems odd to end on an ellipsis.
challenging dark emotional informative reflective sad slow-paced
dark sad medium-paced

A comic book that shows the Palestine in the first intifada, portraying the reality of Palestinians, the men, the women, the old, the young. It is repetitive and tiring, because it is harrowing to know about the violence that is wielded against them daily. Knowing that things have only declined so much more in the decades since, and continues to grow worse, is the truly horrifying fact. 
dark emotional informative reflective sad tense fast-paced
challenging emotional informative sad medium-paced

Looser than more recent Sacco work, yet just as devastating. 

DNF. Usually comic books suck me in! But this was a drudge.