Scan barcode
jupiterfish4's review
challenging
dark
emotional
informative
reflective
sad
slow-paced
3.5
It was pretty dry and I'm glad I listened to it rather than read it. That being said, it was very eye opening for me and I'm really glad for the information it contained. I've never been taught this perspective and it was very sobering, especially juxtaposed with what is taught in American history classes. What the United States considered big wins such as the Louisiana Purchase, Manifest Destiny, and the Homestead Act were completely devastating to the original inhabitants of this continent. Everyone should read this book or a book that covers the same material but may be a little easier to read.
kats_pajamas's review against another edition
informative
reflective
slow-paced
4.75
Graphic: Genocide, Hate crime, and Colonisation
Moderate: Torture, Religious bigotry, and Injury/Injury detail
Minor: Body horror and Child death
siobhanward's review
challenging
informative
4.0
NYT Notable Books 2022: 39/100
This was a really dense, but interesting book. There's a lot of content to absorb, but it's interesting and varied. I appreciated that Hämäläinen didn't just focus on the United States, and that Canadian Indigenous history was also covered in good detail. I knew some of what was covered going in, but not a whole lot, and certainly not to the level of detail that was included. I also appreciated learning the context of things that I didn't know before, like the Battle of Wounded Knee. My biggest gripe is some of the audiobook pronunciations. I know the intention was to pronounce names as close to the tribal pronunciations as possible, but I've never heard Métis pronounced as muh-teece, so it took me a second to realize the author meant Métis.
This was a really dense, but interesting book. There's a lot of content to absorb, but it's interesting and varied. I appreciated that Hämäläinen didn't just focus on the United States, and that Canadian Indigenous history was also covered in good detail. I knew some of what was covered going in, but not a whole lot, and certainly not to the level of detail that was included. I also appreciated learning the context of things that I didn't know before, like the Battle of Wounded Knee. My biggest gripe is some of the audiobook pronunciations. I know the intention was to pronounce names as close to the tribal pronunciations as possible, but I've never heard Métis pronounced as muh-teece, so it took me a second to realize the author meant Métis.
Graphic: Genocide
mdcrouser's review against another edition
informative
reflective
medium-paced
5.0
Exhaustively researched and well-written.
casserole1994's review against another edition
Not my style of history, not easy to follow, too much about the different battles
jouiselouise's review against another edition
I'm not convinced this is the assumption-shattering counternarrative that it claims to be, but I learned a lot, so
georgieem's review against another edition
4.0
Fascinating! Points out how long and multifaceted indigenous peoples across the nation resisted colonial advancement