Take a photo of a barcode or cover
kahn_johnson's review against another edition
5.0
So, some 10-ish years ago someone thrust the first Glasgow trilogy book into my unsuspecting mitt.
I think I liked it, I honestly can't recall, but I do have a lingering memory of that person seeming to be surprised I had read it.
Almost as if they hadn't read it themselves, having only bought it based on the hype and good reviews.
But I digress...
Onwards then, to book two.
The first thing to note, and yes I had forgotten, is the first three pages is the cast of characters. You'll need this as once Mackay gets going he doesn't trouble himself with explaining who anyone is.
You're expected to do your homework here.
But that is just part of the delight that is Mackay's writing.
How A Gunman Says Goodbye is a foot-to-the-floor, dirty and gritty, low-life crime thriller. He hits the gas on line one and doesn't stop until the very abrupt anding.
Underneath the dirt, however, is a deeper tale. One of relationships, growing old, balancing work and your love life.
All told with a dark, sardonic humour.
The only problem with this book is when to read it. Because you need time. A quick chapter here and there won't cut it. Once you start, you'll want to hang on til the final pages.
I think I liked it, I honestly can't recall, but I do have a lingering memory of that person seeming to be surprised I had read it.
Almost as if they hadn't read it themselves, having only bought it based on the hype and good reviews.
But I digress...
Onwards then, to book two.
The first thing to note, and yes I had forgotten, is the first three pages is the cast of characters. You'll need this as once Mackay gets going he doesn't trouble himself with explaining who anyone is.
You're expected to do your homework here.
But that is just part of the delight that is Mackay's writing.
How A Gunman Says Goodbye is a foot-to-the-floor, dirty and gritty, low-life crime thriller. He hits the gas on line one and doesn't stop until the very abrupt anding.
Underneath the dirt, however, is a deeper tale. One of relationships, growing old, balancing work and your love life.
All told with a dark, sardonic humour.
The only problem with this book is when to read it. Because you need time. A quick chapter here and there won't cut it. Once you start, you'll want to hang on til the final pages.
chani_kyne's review against another edition
1.0
I hate sequels that do not continue the main characters story from the first book.
skeltz's review against another edition
4.0
Malcolm Mackay has an odd style of writing but I really enjoy his books. A good read.
raven88's review against another edition
5.0
How A Gunman Says Goodbye is the follow-up to Malcolm Mackay’s exceptional debut novel The Necessary Death of Lewis Winter forming the first two instalments of his Glasgow Trilogy ( the final book, The Sudden Arrival of Violence due to be published January 2014) , and I really don’t know what I can add to the universal praise Mackay has attracted so far. With How A Gunman Says Goodbye, Mackay merely adds to the kudos of his first, with another taut and uncompromising but utterly compelling read, this time focusing on ageing hit man Frank MacLeod, whose comeback from a hip operation, has slightly dulled his formerly razor sharp senses, thereby damaging his long standing reputation as a hit man to fear, and a man whose long term options become increasingly limited…
With the same spare and mesmerising prose that so defined the style and pace of the first book, Mackay cleverly melds moments of tangible compassion with the grim realities of Frank’s future options, that by turn raises empathy, yet an acceptance of the harsh truth within the reader as we see the diminishing of Frank’s usefulness to his former masters. As the pace and coolness of the narrative decreases the passion of the prose, you are so aware of the decreasing circle that Frank finds himself in, with the uncomfortable realisation that his options are decreasing by the hour and that his future is bleak. As Frank considers a life spent at the murderous behest of others, a sad picture comes to light of a life unlived, that is so powerful in its portrayal with the tautness of Mackay’s characterisation and prose. The control of this writing, so illustrative of Mackay’s obvious love of, and homage to, the hardboiled tradition of American crime fiction is a joy, setting him largely apart from his other Scottish crime contemporaries, and highlighting once again the marked difference and freshness he brings to the genre.
Another interesting curve to the story is that we see an interesting reflection of Frank’s potential fate, within his erstwhile protege Calum MacLean (the focal character of the previous book), a relatively young man, who carries the uncomfortable knowledge that Frank’s life casts an unwelcome shadow on his own future, alienated from personal human relationships with a powerful sense of the clock ticking down on his long term usefulness in his chosen profession as a killer for hire. As Frank’s power and position diminishes, Calum’s star rises, but at what cost to old and young man alike, and is this the life that Calum really wants to maintain? After his crisis of conscience following his killing of Lewis Winter in the first book, MacLean is once again grappling with weighty issues, and Mackay’s use of the stream of consciousness both in relation to Frank and Calum is rhythmical and mesmeric adding a pulse to the narrative, as they, and by extension the reader, come to realise the futility of their musings.
Mackay has once again brought us a brutal and dispassionate tale of the Glasgow underworld, but so cleverly undercut with moments of extreme poignancy that resonate with the reader on a very human level. A crime novel that is spare but emotive, beautifully constructed with an unrelenting tense pace, and compelling to the very end, thanks in no small part to the exceptional characterisation and Mackay’s ability to depict the violent underbelly of gangland Glasgow. A remarkable read.
With the same spare and mesmerising prose that so defined the style and pace of the first book, Mackay cleverly melds moments of tangible compassion with the grim realities of Frank’s future options, that by turn raises empathy, yet an acceptance of the harsh truth within the reader as we see the diminishing of Frank’s usefulness to his former masters. As the pace and coolness of the narrative decreases the passion of the prose, you are so aware of the decreasing circle that Frank finds himself in, with the uncomfortable realisation that his options are decreasing by the hour and that his future is bleak. As Frank considers a life spent at the murderous behest of others, a sad picture comes to light of a life unlived, that is so powerful in its portrayal with the tautness of Mackay’s characterisation and prose. The control of this writing, so illustrative of Mackay’s obvious love of, and homage to, the hardboiled tradition of American crime fiction is a joy, setting him largely apart from his other Scottish crime contemporaries, and highlighting once again the marked difference and freshness he brings to the genre.
Another interesting curve to the story is that we see an interesting reflection of Frank’s potential fate, within his erstwhile protege Calum MacLean (the focal character of the previous book), a relatively young man, who carries the uncomfortable knowledge that Frank’s life casts an unwelcome shadow on his own future, alienated from personal human relationships with a powerful sense of the clock ticking down on his long term usefulness in his chosen profession as a killer for hire. As Frank’s power and position diminishes, Calum’s star rises, but at what cost to old and young man alike, and is this the life that Calum really wants to maintain? After his crisis of conscience following his killing of Lewis Winter in the first book, MacLean is once again grappling with weighty issues, and Mackay’s use of the stream of consciousness both in relation to Frank and Calum is rhythmical and mesmeric adding a pulse to the narrative, as they, and by extension the reader, come to realise the futility of their musings.
Mackay has once again brought us a brutal and dispassionate tale of the Glasgow underworld, but so cleverly undercut with moments of extreme poignancy that resonate with the reader on a very human level. A crime novel that is spare but emotive, beautifully constructed with an unrelenting tense pace, and compelling to the very end, thanks in no small part to the exceptional characterisation and Mackay’s ability to depict the violent underbelly of gangland Glasgow. A remarkable read.
celtic67's review against another edition
3.0
Did not enjoy this as book one. Will not bother with book three
duparker's review against another edition
4.0
There is something both basic and primal about these books and exciting and innovative. On the one hand something very simple happens and there's clear outcomes, but there's an excitement as you try to read what's going to happen knowing what probably will or should happen. The people seem real the action seems realistic in the book itself is very enjoyable.
eiseneisen's review against another edition
4.0
This is going to be a brief review, because I have to get started on book 3 of the Glasgow Trilogy. Suffice to say that How a Gunman Says Goodbye is a worthy follow up to The Necessary Death of Lewis Winter. A fast-paced and gripping continuation of the story of Calum MacClean and the criminal underground of Glasgow. Two-thirds through, this trilogy is proving to be the perfect summertime reading choice. Strongly recommended.