Reviews

Custer Died for Your Sins: An Indian Manifesto by Vine Deloria Jr.

smccauley422's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

I learned a tremendous amount reading this book, both gaining totally new information, and a new perspective on previous information.

john_rileys_ghost's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

When you read a book that's over 30 years old, and much of it remains relevant, especially when it's a manifesto ripe with biting social critique, it kind of stings a little. It makes you bitter while you read it. Deloria's book here manages that while providing humorous insights and perspectives, at both times a history and a proposal for moving forward. While dated in some aspects, specifically in regards to his views & statements on the Black power movements (or I just flat out disagree with his assessment of militant, violent political movements of the 1970s), Deloria can and should be applauded here for attempting to assess the myriad ways political movements can potentially engage with each other, and the ways in which they can fail.

Of most interest and perhaps utility to modern readers would be Deloria's takes on nationalism and tribalism, and how they can provide vehicles for movements to see their way through white supremacy and colonialism. Leftists will probably hesitate at these terms, as I have and still often do, but in the context of colonialism and decolonization we must broaden our definitions and perspectives of how these terms can exist beyond and against xenophobia and white supremacy.

I look forward to thinking about this book for a long time.

vagrantshark's review against another edition

Go to review page

informative reflective medium-paced

4.0


Expand filter menu Content Warnings

arbitrarytree's review against another edition

Go to review page

funny informative medium-paced

3.75

nibellarin's review

Go to review page

5.0

Super important read. Going to reread with family. Looking forward to getting back into his other work, "God is Red". This shows a much more nuanced picture of the state of "Indian" affairs as of the 1970's and 80's and is strikingly similar to some aspects we see today. It is funny at times, painfully blunt and honest at others and engaging all the way through.

This book makes me want to explore further the nature of individualism vs. tribalism. Deloria points out later in the book that much of society in America became corporate tribalism even as tribes were forcibly shifted to individuals and continuously divided. Honestly, the more I understand about the differences and how they effect the psyche of a populace, the more individualism scares me. Another book I read awhile ago goes into how the Chilean people were made to feel just how 'individual' they were through torture and psychological trauma. I see that we did this shit first, to Native Americans.

Another thing this book shows me is how easily one can turn another human being into an object, losing site of the people for the cause or the money or the land.

I started off borrowing this one after purchasing and starting into Deloria's later work, "God is Red". Later, I bought it. Now I feel like I can go into his next work with a bit more understanding of his perspective.

Really worth reading. Really important reading.

ppival's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Wow. Written 50 years ago and I'll bet pretty much everything described is still the same. 😟

kelleieio's review against another edition

Go to review page

Tough subject, enjoyed the sarcastic tone.

lynzobergs's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

This was a great analysis of lots of different aspects of Indian life in the US, and how the government, church, archaeologists/academia, and other outside forces have shaped the situation in 1968 (when the book was published). It's amazing that this was released over 50 years ago when it seems some of these issues are still currently being dealt with (or, in most cases, NOT dealt with).

The author's biting wit definitely pushed me to continue - each chapter is pretty long and has few breaks, and I didn't absorb some of the more technical legal details - and I really appreciated the last chapter about the future of recolonization. As a descendant of european immigrants/colonizers, I'm ready. From what I've been learning, this country would be much better if we adopted some Indigenous practices (GOODBYE, CAPITALISM!) and gave all of the #LANDBACK

skorned's review

Go to review page

challenging informative inspiring medium-paced

4.75

This is an excellent book; despite its age, many of the points (humorous and informative alike) remain salient and timely. Yes there are some ideas and arguments that don't stand up to the test of time, but I understand why it's a seminal Native work.

nightingaelic's review against another edition

Go to review page

challenging funny informative medium-paced

4.5

Some of this book is out of date - most of it is not. Vine Deloria Jr., through a combination of scathing criticism and howling humor, will make you consider the ways American Indians are excluded, punished, and overridden for the simple crime of refusing to disappear from the world. I learned things about tribes I had lived near for years, completely oblivious to the injustices they had been dealt by the United States government in just the past century. Everyone should read this.