You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Scan barcode
ashycampbell's review against another edition
3.0
Good story, well written, but didn’t care enough about each storyline.
prittyinpinkdiva's review against another edition
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
2.25
4.5 stars for how captivating the book was (especially the audiobook) but 1.5 stars for historical fiction that feels ahistorical.
—
Page turner but I have major concerns about the historical accuracy. The author portrays white men as violent and/or negligent - but fails to capture white women’s active participation in slavery.
White women are repeatedly portrayed as benevolent (teaching enslaved people to read, offering to buy an enslaved man’s freedom, helping protect a runaway slave). None of these things are stand out, but they really added up over the course of the book to the point where I noticed a pattern - white women are portrayed as passive and somewhat unwilling participants in slavery. The author admits in the closing that there is no evidence that white town members attempted to free the ensalved man she writes about - so why write that fantasy?
One of our main characters, Sally, is portrayed as principled, critical of patriarchy, and generally kind to enslaved people. YET, the author briefly mentions that she is a slave owner herself. The author doesn’t seem to know what to do with white women’s participation in slavery nor does she know how to write this complexity in her characters.
—
Page turner but I have major concerns about the historical accuracy. The author portrays white men as violent and/or negligent - but fails to capture white women’s active participation in slavery.
White women are repeatedly portrayed as benevolent (teaching enslaved people to read, offering to buy an enslaved man’s freedom, helping protect a runaway slave). None of these things are stand out, but they really added up over the course of the book to the point where I noticed a pattern - white women are portrayed as passive and somewhat unwilling participants in slavery. The author admits in the closing that there is no evidence that white town members attempted to free the ensalved man she writes about - so why write that fantasy?
One of our main characters, Sally, is portrayed as principled, critical of patriarchy, and generally kind to enslaved people. YET, the author briefly mentions that she is a slave owner herself. The author doesn’t seem to know what to do with white women’s participation in slavery nor does she know how to write this complexity in her characters.
cgarner7's review against another edition
4.0
It’s crazy that this fire became the greatest calamity in terms of sudden loss of life that the relatively young United States had ever experienced; and not many know about the experiences these people faced.
Loved the different perspectives; it really helped engage me and allowed for a great pacing. I may be back to read this one again very soon.
Loved the different perspectives; it really helped engage me and allowed for a great pacing. I may be back to read this one again very soon.
amazonanne's review against another edition
5.0
Beautifully written and historically as accurate as a non-fiction book can be. Fascinating story of the burning of a theater in Richmond VA in the early 1800’s, as told from the viewpoint of four separate people. Part mystery. Part history. Part feminist commentary. Definitely recommend.
rigorous_reader's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
inspiring
sad
tense
fast-paced
4.0
mlefever1's review against another edition
4.0
Interesting take on a historical event. Quick read. Lots of dialogue. No real surprises.