Reviews

Do You Dream of Terra-Two? by Temi Oh

patchworkbunny's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Terra-Two is humanity's hope for the future. A new planet. A new chance at life. Ten specially selected astronauts will make the first journey and start the process of colonisation. It will take 23 years to get there, so six young adults are selected to accompany the more experienced astronauts. But things start to go wrong even before they've left Earth...

Do You Dream of Terra-Two? is a character driven exploration of what happens when you send a group of barely adult astronauts on a one-way mission. It's set in an alternate version of history, where a planet was discovered a hundred years ago which could sustain human life. That planet is Terra Two, its discovery fuelling a space race and resulting in Britain having a space programme.

The younger astronauts attended the elite school of Dalton. The story starts as they find out if they've been chosen or not. They come from various backgrounds but have all been working towards the dream of Terra-Two for years. I loved getting to know them all. The focus is on the young adults, and I do say young adults over teenagers as they are pushing twenty. The themes are reminiscent of the new adult sub-genre that failed to really emerge a few years ago.

Whilst they knew each other at Dalton, and Astrid and Juno are twins, they are not really friends with each other. They must learn to live in close quarters, having arguments over missing chores, or being a bit too competitive. Harry is suspicious of Eliot and Jesse and Poppy retreats from social interactions.

They must all come to terms with their decision to leave Earth. It's not action-packed, even when emergency strikes, it's often drawn out, much like life in space must be in reality. The science generally seemed quite close to real, current day science too. It felt like it was written by someone fascinated with space travel. I loved my time with them and felt attached when it was time to say goodbye.

I was a little sceptical for much of the book on the size and selection of the crew. Why only ten people, when something could easily incapacitate them in 23 years? They supposedly had strict psychological evaluations at Dalton, so how on earth did this bunch make it? Harry is not fit to be a leader with his arrogance and bullying. Juno has an eating disorder, one she has been doing her best to hide. Poppy is depressed. And then there was the suicide at the start. However, during one conversation, the characters also ponder this, maybe they had ulterior motives for sending this crew.

wethefoxen's review against another edition

Go to review page

dark emotional slow-paced

3.0

goldendevil1711's review against another edition

Go to review page

fast-paced
The premise of this book was really interesting, but I felt like it just never really delivered on it. Not a terrible book, but not one I'd recommend to anyone either.

frances_l's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous emotional tense medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

4.5

morganl_'s review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous emotional reflective tense medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.5

staralfur's review against another edition

Go to review page

1.0

I could not get past how badly this space program is run, and I've listed some of the issues below (lots of spoilers!):

Spoiler
-They didn't notice and/or care about serious mental and/or physical illnesses in their crew. This includes hallucinations, antisocial behavior, eating disorders and cancer. Despite of most of the crew members being in their care for many years.
-They didn't postpone the mission when one of the crew members committed suicide the day before launch. The reason given is vague, something about having sold tickets to watch the launch. I dunno, I would assume the cost of a failed launch/mission of this magnitude far outweighs the loss of the tickets sold.
-They fired the crew member in charge of their health because of the suicide, and replaced her with someone new that the rest of the crew did not know. Just before launch. A completely new person they don't know. This seems risky.
-They did not train the backup crew in the exact same things as the main crew (doesn't that defeat the purpose of a backup crew?)
-They did not instruct the crew on what sort of society they were going to form on this new planet, apparently they didn't think about this at all, and the crew members didn't notice that they lacked this information.
-They did not seem to train the crew very well in handling isolation, nor did they consider the compatibility between the crew members as important, apparently..? This seems like a flaw when you're putting a bunch of people together with no way to escape, for two decades.
-They plan on putting pregnant women in cryosleep to travel, and it is not explained why they don't do this with the first crew. If they have the technology, surely this is something they could do to all or some of the first crew, rather than have them be awake and aware for 23 years.
-There are some conspiracy theories launched towards the end, about how the people in charge knew that there would only be about a 20% chance of success, and also that maybe they didn't pick the best people. This isn't explored further, and does not help. Why would they risk losing this much money, not to mention their face and reputation if it was ever discovered that they were up to something this unethical? The competition aspect between nations does not seem strong enough. It is possible that this would be the author's ticket to explain away all of the other issues too, but it is just not explained. Possibly because of how the story is told, through the eyes of the youngest members of the crew.


I liked the idea, a crew slowly on its way to a possible paradise. I also liked the author's prose. But immersion was impossible for me, because of all of the issues above.

PS: I actually wanted to like this book so much that I accidentally bought it twice. Two different covers.

talonsontypewriters's review

Go to review page

emotional reflective slow-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? It's complicated
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

2.5


Expand filter menu Content Warnings

sillyhily's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous challenging dark emotional reflective sad medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? It's complicated
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.0


I really picked this book up because of the title, the glitchy Terra-two paperback cover, and it had a sci-fi sticker at my local library. I did not intend to fall so deeply into its grasp and find myself bounding through chapters as quickly as I did. I found it so tragically gripping an idea from the beginning and I needed to explore more. It was truly as fucked up as I’d hoped it would be, in better more interesting ways than I could’ve imagined.

The characters through which you understand the story were so devastatingly young and that was never once forgotten. They experienced the trauma that is becoming one's self in the void of space with limited company. Individuals all of which were so unique and intentional. The backgrounds were a catalyst for the storytelling, they helped you understand how they came to be and how they would come to understand each other. I was gripping this novel knowing that the young characters could not yet comprehend the lengths and bounds at which they are growing and learning. I could feel myself, younger again, similarly lost desperate for answers and definitives, which is why this novel had me so critically in its vice. The twists and turns were so unexpected and empathetically crafted to carry the story adrift to the far end of our galaxy.

Minor critic at most, I wanted more about the world. I can understand why we have such a limited perspective considering the characters are children. Often, most children have limited understanding and comprehension of their world, much less, when they are thrust into outer space at a meager eighteen. Even without the complete understanding of the world the timeframe it was set in is certainly strategically chosen. I can remember 2012, how desperate the world was to understand at the very dawn of the age of technology that would change the face of the world as we knew it. 2012 was so distinct. But I am still left wondering what this fictional earth was like, mainly mentioned in passing, I found myself so confused by technological advancements while still confounded by its deficits. Other than just wanting more of the world, I also desperately wanted to know the adults, specifically the ones also on the mission. Every time the children did something audacious and reflected on their ever calm and stern veteran astronaut team I could feel myself itching to know more about them. Children tend not to know how complex adults can be because they themselves are so carried away with their own interesting and unique lives. But I do see how this is the children's story, not the adults, I just found myself wishing for a chapter from each of them to see how they understood the children they were tasked with caring for. And how their perspectives changed on the outcome of the mission as the story moves along. Specifically, it also would've been interesting to hear about the Physician position, and if those characters were included then seeing the switch of perspectives when characters are shifted for the mission. Similar to how Jesse's recount is hopeful, it could've been an interesting juxtaposition to see both physicians' reactions. 

NOTE on the character of Harry: 
Possibly quite an unpopular opinion from what I've noticed in many people's reviews on different platforms, but, I disagree with ignoring the character of Harry and his choices so quickly. I don't think he's particularly the "villain" of the story, but he is a major bully, assisted by his gender, class, and race, which garnered him immediate status over the other children of the mission. For Harry's character and this representation of him in the book to make it to the final draft is quite a commentary on the way the patriarchy, racism, and sexism persist in this fictional world as well. We have quite a limited lens, because the main characters barely scrape into young adulthood before they are sentenced to the mission, but Harry is a very clear representation of what is happening down on earth. I think that not acknowledging how he refuses to see the humanity in Jesse until Jesse risks his own life for Harry and Poppy's survival is to negate the author's words. Harry, the image of a patriarchal society and the result of generational wealth, could not, until he was faced with certain death and subsequently saved from it by someone he previously deemed unfit to stand alongside him, recognize the humanity in another person. Harry, in the text, uses Poppy, the young beautiful white woman, for sex and attention, terrorizes Jesses, a man he doesn't deem worthy of the status of being on the mission, and ignores everyone else for basically the entire book unless they have a position of power which he deems worthy of possessing, and his closeness to those adult characters is only in an effort to gain their power and wield it for himself. He sucks, I don't give a fuck if he "had a hard life"??? Boo hoo. Cry somewhere else. 
All this to say I loved the book and the characterization of Harry by Temi Oh, which I thought to be one of the most valuable contributions and done in a very strategic and thoughtful way.
 
 

Expand filter menu Content Warnings

katiegrrrl's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

This is kind of slow but the end really packs a punch. I am still thinking about it.

cowardlycod's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous mysterious tense medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? It's complicated
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes

3.5