Reviews

Kazananın Öpücüğü by Marie Rutkoski

agall645's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

*4.5 stars
I did a review on my blog!Check it out to hear my thoughts: http://aideensbookobsession.blogspot.com/2016/06/the-winners-kiss-by-marie-rutkoski.html

thevintagechronicles's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Libby/audio

I have to give this series credit for being a YA political fantasy in a time when Dystopia was the it thing. That said, this series has a lot of elements that seem to pop up out of nowhere. The first book was my favorite of the bunch. (It's simply an average series though). The end of the second book intrigued me, and this book starts out where that one left off. 

Kestrel is hauled off to a prison camp. Im not sure what they are mining, but poisons are used to docile the prisoners. They work incredibly well. They are hinted at in book two in a minor role. (but in later events, I'm surprised they are not utilized. (Ie: the betrayal of the general against Kestrel, why doesn't the Emperor use it on his son, Kestrel? My only guess is that they die eventually.)

She is eventually rescued after a frankly laughable delay by Arin, but has memory loss. I enjoyed the journey back between them. And her journey to gaining her memory back. 

But this brings me to a gripe i had with this book. Arin in the last book, while held prisoner in the Eastern (hostile) land kisses the Queen. At this point, Kestrel spent the entirety of last book engaged to the Prince, and repeatedly insulted/rejected him (Arin) through until the very end. He has the impression that she wants nothing to do with him. Obviously we know this is mostly untrue, and that they both obviously love each other, and she has no choice but to lie. 

Needless to say, he loves her, so after this kiss, where he is trying very hard to pretend the Queen is Kestrel(and i would argue the queen is actually the aggressor/power player here) he stops it, and goes off to win a war. Circling back, he kisses this lady. Okay. That sucks. He feels guilty and he confesses. Kestrel also kissed the prince in the last book,  i believe. She has no guilt. (Book 2 particularly suffers a lot on miscommunication) Anyway(sorry, squirrel! ) my point is that in this book Arin is constantly bending over backward/walking on eggshells and apologizing to Kestrel. This isn't the only subject he acts this way about. It's constant. He is always subservient to her. Let's not forget that this series starts out with him being purchased by her as her slave.
It's not that i have a problem with his attitude per se. But she is actually the one who lied, who hides things, who keeps secrets, who betrays people, who sneaks off and puts herself in danger (and has to be rescued), who makes mistakes that get people hurt, who refuses to risk herself/her feelings/her heart for Arin. She is wrong most of the time. She never apologizes or grovels. It's really irritating. 

Then we have this weird god touched/god of death element that comes out of nowhere. It's convenient. For sure. 

Kestrel fights in some battles, i suppose that could have been worse, considering her history and her refusal to learn to fight in book one. She does win more often than it feels like she should, but she doesn't magically know how to do a lot more than before, I suppose. Also, Arin somehow is a bit magical in his warrior fighting skills, so idk, it's just odd all around i guess. 

The story i believe is written in 3rd person(i may be wrong-but it isn't 1st person) which makes the story ping pong between characters, and though that tension can be exhilarating at times, it really prevented me from being highly attached to these characters. 

The best i can say is the series is okay. I don't love the world or the final outcome. I liked this book more than the second, the second left me feeling icky and uneasy, and this one at least brings the MCs back together, and moving together toward the climax. It has more action. It still left me feeling unsatisfied ultimately, and many aspects are kind of dropped. (The drugs/god-touched) i still have questions, but thankfully this is the final book, and i can move on with my life. 

Overall, i guess it wasn't for me. 

katep27's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

3/5stars

I definitely think this was an instance of "it's not the book - it's me."

I had been looking forward to this finale since I finished the second book last summer. I preordered it and began reading it the second I picked it up from my mailbox.
Unfortunately, I seem to be in a YA-reading slump. For months now, I haven't seemed to be able to read YA, and everytime I do I just can't seem to enjoy what I'm reading. I thought this book, because of my huge excitement and overall love for the series, would bring me out of this weird "not able to read young adult" funk I've been in - but it didn't.

This story was definitely interesting and I really loved the direction it went it.
The writing style was BEAUTIFUL, it flowed wonderfully and was even better than I remember the first two books being!
But, having to wait so long in between books made me forget MANY details, characters and events that happened earlier in the trilogy.
I was also unable to connect at all to any of the characters or their thoughts.

I do plan on giving this entire series a marathon-reread to fully enjoy it. But for now, I'm pretty "meh" about this last book.

erin_lawless's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

4 stars. The weakest of the trilogy, I thought, but - of course - that still allows plenty of room for it to be really, really good! I think maybe I missed the political intrigue - and I wasn't a huge fan of the convenient soap opera amnesia - but I am just looking for negatives really. The whole series was amazing, a definite forever favourite, and Kestrel and Arin are both brilliant protagonists. The strong, slow burn romance in these books is exquisite - I barely slept for three days while I binge read the first two installments - and that same lyrical story is carried on here, tempered by the genuinely clever military strategies, twists and about-faces.

You need to read this series. It's damn near perfect.

bookish_platypus's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous dark emotional sad medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

5.0

I was afraid this wasn't going to end well but this was such a good final book!

maggieha's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

“You don't need to be gifted with a blade. You are your own best weapon.”

Absolutely brilliant! The Winner's Kiss was very near perfection for me, and it's definitely my favourite from the trilogy, though The Winner's Curse is pretty close behind. I will miss this beautiful gem of a story and its characters very much, but I also know that this is one of those series that I will always come back to eventually. One of those tales which will truly stay with me.


Some of my favourite quotes:

“As he spoke, it occurred to her that maybe he, too, felt like two people, that maybe everybody does, and that it’s not a question of whether one’s damaged, but of how easily or not that damage is seen.”


“He changed us both." She seemed to struggle for words. "I think of you, all that you lost, who you were, what you were forced to be, and might have been, and I—I have become this, this person, unable to—"
She shut her mouth.
"Kestrel," he said softly, "I love this person.”



“Kestrel felt a slow, slight throb, a shimmer in the blood. She knew it well.
Her worst trait. Her best trait.
The desire to come out on top, to set her opponent under her thumb.
A streak of pride. Her mind ringed with hungry rows of foxlike teeth.”



“I happen to be very good at war. It’s because I’m so handsome. Like one of your gods. People see me and their minds go blank. I run my sword right through them.”

<-- Roshar represented the much needed comic relief throughout this dark story. I surprisingly love his character!


“Will you come with me?"
"Ah, Kestrel, that's something you never need to ask.”



She thought of her past. Her whole life. "I want better choices."
"Then we must make a world that has them."

_lavanyaaa_'s review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Rating: 4⭑˚.⋆
Date: 23/01/25
Format: E-book


As I’m writing this review, it has been two days since I finished this series and I don’t know what do with my life anymore. I’ll keep this brief though because if I think about this trilogy too much, I’ll go into a spiral.

To start off, I loved this book. I loved it. There were a few inconsistencies with the ending but I loved the previous 90% too much not to mention it. One thing I’ve noticed in a majority of YA dystopian/fantasy books where the main characters have to overthrow an oppressive regime is that there is always only a single battle?? One fight and the bad guys who’ve been running their business for decades (even centuries, in some books) are trampled by a bunch of teenagers? The complete opposite happened in The Winner’s Kiss. This book was entirely set in a battlefield and there was SO much fighting, and so much strategising. I loved the moments where Kestrel would come up with another clever idea to save everyone!!

I loved the addition of a new character, Roshar. He was hilarious and SO fun to read about. His presence added a sense of found family and warmth that the previous two books were lacking. I loved his and Arin’s friendship so much!!

elisedavis20's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous reflective medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.0

screaming_into_the_void's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous dark emotional mysterious tense fast-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.0

kmcphers's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

If we're being completely honest, the only thing I hated about this book was the title. Other than that this was the best trilogy ending every, like it hit everything. Action? Um duh. Romance? see title. Heartbreaking moment of awesomeness that question your sanity? yeah, I really shouldn't care for fictional characters as much as I do. This book was a lot darker than its previous installments, and you can tell Marie Rutkoski did a lot of research into war and strategy, very detailed (I have no clue if it's accurate because I know nothing about warfare, but it seemed legitimate). Like there were prison camps and brutal descriptions of killing. It also explored emotions in a way not typically seen in YA novels- characters weren't just flatly seeking vengeance, or flatly falling in love with people- there were facets. I can't go into anymore detail without spoiling, but it was lovely. The plot twist at the end (I won't reveal) was the best plot twist every. Like awesome. Wow. Did not see that coming. So good.

Overall, great ending, could not have asked for anything more.