I'm having some trouble gathering my thoughts on this book and series. Maybe I'll come back and edit this review at some later point, because I'm not sure how coherent or comprehensive this one will be.

What I can say is this series has been the first fantasy series I've fallen in love with since I was in middle school. I think the world-building is truly second to none, and the concept and delivery of these books feels refreshingly different to me. The phrase "brought to life" is somewhat overused as a descriptor for writing, in my opinion, but I truly felt it with this series. I found the world and characters incredibly believable. The way Lee writes her characters, the strengths and weaknesses each possess feel like two sides of the same coin in a way that feels very natural, and I believe contributes to their overall credibility and realism. The fact that, despite the evolution and growth of every character throughout the roughly 25-30 year span during which this series is set, these characters retain their believability, is a testament to Lee's ability to create lifelike characters.

I will say the extended time period for the trilogy was something that frustrated me at times. There is an incredible amount of political and corporate intrigue within this series, but so much of it is more...hinted at, rather than fully-explored. I think this trilogy easily could have been a longer series if Lee chose to delve into those aspects more fully. I respect that she didn't want to slow the pacing and action too much, but so many impactful plot details being sidenotes throughout the series made it somewhat difficult to keep track of things at times, in my opinion. Or maybe I just wasn't paying close enough attention.  

Anyways, despite the occasional frustration, it's a choice that paid off in the end, in my opinion. This extended time period contributes to the epic scale of the story, and allows Lee to give her characters truly fitting and satisfying endings that I don't think would have been so impactful if Lee hadn't shown how the characters and grown and evolved throughout 30 years of their lives.

In particular, Hilo's ending is just epic. Frankly, it was always obvious that Hilo isn't the type of character to fade quietly into the night. The fact that he knows that too is what I always liked about him. His last stand, foreshadowed early on and then subverted again and again and again, was the perfect ending to one of the most satisfying character journey's I've ever encountered. Ayt Mada being forced to retire and live out her days in humiliation is similarly a perfect ending to her story. I love how both of their endings reflect the values of the Green Bone society that Lee had painstakingly developed over the course of this trilogy. In the real world, death isn't often something epic or consequential. But within Lee's universe and the context of Kekon's Green Bone culture, it almost feels like a victory.

Just in general, an extremely satisfying end to an epic story, even if sometimes I felt like the time skips were a little jarring.

Also, I just want to say again how much I love the characters. Hilo honestly might be my favourite fictional character ever. I love how dramatic, vindictive, and ruthless he can be, while simultaneously having a huge heart and always putting his family before himself. His growth from a bloodthirsty loose cannon in the first novel to a ruthlessly pragmatic and respectable patriach was such an amazing character journey. I also loved seeing Anden go from insecure teenager to a highly competent and reliable adult. Wen's and Shae's female perspectives within such a male-dominated society added a huge amount of depth to the story, and I enjoyed how Lee portrayed both as having their own strengths and capabilities that contributed to the war effort, while also allowing them to maintain their femininity. And even though his character arc was mostly limited to this final installment, I found Niko's journey to be very eventful and was very fascinated by his portrayal. 

I'm so glad I was able to spend time with these characters, and I truly loved this series. Amazing work by Fonda Lee. 

I can’t believe I finally finished this trilogy. It’s one that will definitely sit with me for a long time because I love books that make the reader question what it means to be a good or bad person. For about a week, I’ve lived inside this book and felt a roller coaster of emotions. The Kaul’s and all of the characters in these books are extremely flawed but Lee portrayed each person with such complexities, individuality, and empathy that I felt connected to them. I desperately want to see this trilogy as a film series or streaming show.

Truly an epic. A fitting ending to the trilogy. Fonda Lee has done a masterful job bringing readers on this journey and wraps everything up here in a way that feels true to the story.

The Grand Finale!!!
This book was a once-in-a-lifetime kind of book that I will never forget.
     What Fonda achieved with this trilogy is astonishing and unforgettable. Fonda created a world with people that will stick with me for a long time. Reading and experiencing the Kaul family's lives over the span of 20+ years, seeing their flaws and strengths bring them together, was truly inspiring. This trilogy changed the standard settings for fantasies to come.
     The greatest thing about The GreenBone Saga is its characters. Hilo is probably one of the most complex characters ever written. From the way, he's harsh and brutal to kind and loving. He had one of the best character arcs in the series. Anden started out as a side character for me but had my entire heart and soul by the end of the series. Amazing to see him finding not only who he was as a person but also stepping up and taking his role in the clan. Shae, my girl. Throughout all the darkness and evil she still remained kind and mercifully which, in this world was impressive. All the characters shined in this finale. It was a different kind of emotion seeing the new generation of greenbones grow up and take on roles in the clans. The dynamic between the parents and kids really shined. 
     The world-building is the second most incredible thing about this trilogy. I was truly impressed and touched by the way Kekon fought for their island. Fought for what was their legacy as they faced threats from outside forces but also from within the island itself. The jade itself was the star of the show. Fonda Lee did not just show us how people with access to jade treated and handled the privileged that comes with being jade warriors, but also the jade-less people and how they were affected by the clan wars and the jade. 
     The Greenbone Saga is for those who love to read about complex characters that make equally bad and good choices in life. That loves family dynamics and relations. That loves politics with scheming and plotting. That loves action and fighting scenes. 
     The Greenbone Saga is for those who wish to find a series with characters that will make you love them, care for them and defend them for better-or-worse

A highly satisfying and emotional end to what I think might be the most ambitious and unique fantasy trilogy I've ever read. Here is my spoiler-free review of the entire Green Bone Saga trilogy:

Well, 2022 was the year I finally read the Green Bone Saga by Fonda Lee, and—having now come out the other side of 'Jade Legacy' with my heart relatively in tact—I'm happy to report it was one of the most thrilling, satisfying, ambitious, epic and unique fantasy stories I've ever read in my entire life. It's not really a trilogy so much as one enormous book split into three parts, and I think that's worth bearing in mind if you find yourself slogging a bit through some of the info-dumps in 'Jade City'. A contemporary-feeling high urban fantasy that encompasses literally ✨decades✨ of time across multiple generations around an entire fictional globe, featuring a myriad of cultures, customs and creeds... Cor blimy, Fonda Lee doesn't like doing things by halves, does she?! From the gang-ridden streets of 'Jade City' all the way up to the geopolitical family melodrama of 'Jade Legacy', the Green Bone Saga had me by the throat even days after finishing. I fear it still does. Reader, I've left my heart in Janloon.

The Green Bone Saga tells the story of the Kaul family of the No Peak clan in the Asian-inspired city of Janloon on the isle of Kekon. The Kaul family and others like them are Green bones; people with the ability to carry and wield bioenergetic "jade"; a magical substance that enhances users abilities in the six disciplines of Strength, Steel, Perception, Lightness, Deflection and Channelling.  Kaul Lanshinwan, the Pillar of No Peak, is trying to navigate the hostile advances of No Peak's greatest rival, the Mountain Clan, headed up by the ruthless Ayt Madashi. With tension brewing between the clans, and trouble stirring across the ocean between world superpowers, Ygutan and Espenia, Lan must also try and rein in his brother Hilo, the hot-headed Horn of No Peak, and keep him from lighting the spark that starts an all-out war.

It is impossible for me to name any one area where Green Bone  shines, because truthfully, all of it does. Characters, plot, world-building and writing style,... all of it is hyper-focused, meticulously planned, and delivered to the reader in the most effective, and emotionally devastating way possible.

Let's start with the writing. Fonda Lee is not what I'd call a pretty writer, but there's an evocative bluntness to her prose that really works for the style of story she's trying to tell. Sentences are beautifully constructed, but with all the grit left in, such as this gem from 'Jade City''s opening paragraph: "Summer had barely begun and already the city of Janloon was like a spent lover—sticky and fragrant."

The plot primarily is driven by the characters and how they interact with one another. It is intriguing, thrilling, twisty and shocking, and moves along at a steadily building pace. Every now and then, even as early as 'Jade City', Fonda Lee will hit you with a massive unexpected and game-changing event that will change the course of everything you know, then start building up the pace all over again. As the end of all three books draws to a close, the downtime between each climactic event gets less and less and less, until you reach 'Jade Legacy' at which point everything starts moving at breakneck speed, and you can hardly catch your breath. SO good. I found 'Jade City' to be a bit on the slow side but I found myself losing sleep to finish 'Jade War' and 'Jade Legacy' was no different. Rest assured, these are books you will not want to put down.

Speaking of characters and how they drive the plot, I guarantee that by the end of this trilogy, you will have fallen in love with the entire Kaul family. Lan, Hilo, Shae, Anden, Wen and the Maik brothers all hold places within my heart, and I reckon I've shaved years off my life in becoming so ill-advisedly invested in their wellbeing. For much of the trilogy, the misunderstood Anden and fiercely resourceful Wen were my favourites, but it was Hilo who ultimately took the top spot around halfway through 'Jade War'. The man is a masterful creation; reckless, vindictive, fiercely loyal, vengeful and utterly brutal, Hilo is a veritable powder keg of unpredictability. Things are never dull when Hilo's around, and it was so much fun watching him grow and change over the years. I was always equal parts scared and excited about where the story was going, wondering what horrible, game-changing thing Hilo would do next.

As for the world-building, this is hands down the most ambitious, comprehensive and believable fantasy world I have ever read in my life. As someone who considers themselves reasonably well-versed in the fantasy genre, I do not say this lightly. Green Bone culture permeates every aspect of Kekonese lives including their socialisation with others (including people whose cultures are vastly different to theirs such as the westernised Espenians), their politians, their economy, their medicine, their military, their expats and accompanying disapora, their crime rates, their black market, racism, xenophobia, ordinary citizens... everything. Fonda Lee takes absolutely everything into account so you know exactly where jade comes from, what it means to the people of Kekon and the rest of the world, and how far people are willing to go to get it. Starting you off primarily on the isle of Kekon in 'Jade City', Fonda Lee throws the net wider in 'Jade War' by deepening the ties between Kekon and the rest of the world, then throws it even wider still in 'Jade Legacy' with the introduction of additional factions borne of a result of the events in books 1 and 2. The nuance and skill with which all of this is handled is absolutely stunning.

Overall, the Green Bone Saga was hands down the best thing I read in 2022 and has become a new favourite. It is slick, smart, thoroughly modern, and one of those torch bearing fantasies that pushes the genre in directions you didn't even know it could go. I thoroughly recommend this trilogy to absolutely all fantasy fans, and I am on my knees begging you all to add 'Jade City' to your TBR immediately. You won't regret it!

 

I did it! This chonk of a book, over 700 pages, is the final installment of the Green Bone Saga...and I have conquered it! It took me an extra four renewals at the library (thank goodness for staff privileges and no one else having it on hold - the guilt of someone else waiting would have really stressed me out). I buried myself deep into it over the recent Holiday long weekend and, once I gave myself that space and time to settle in, got through the final two thirds in just two days. And what a finale it was! 

 

In Jade City, the story focused on the city of Janloon, in the country of Kekon, introducing us to the Kaul family, leaders of the No Peak clan and their rival Mountain clan. In Jade War, the story moves outward, as other countries get involved in the fight for dominance of jade, the substance that enhances a person's innate physical/intuitive abilities, and No Peak and Mountain start leveraging international influence against each other in sort of proxy wars. And here in Jade Legacy, the focus is split between the intra- and extra- national struggles for power. As the Kaul family grows, despite familial angst and drama, they stand together against all their enemies: the Mountain clan in particular, and in defense of Kekon against outside interests in general. While at the same time, the Mountain clan, whose ruthlessness and willingness to partner with any ally, has long been a step ahead in their years-long feud, seems on the verge of finally "winning" in the fight to control Kekon and the jade trade worldwide. However, the Kaul family has a few final moves to make, that could prove with finality that family is the strongest of all powers, and with a new generation of leaders on the horizon, maybe it actually is possible to move beyond grudges and vengeance in partnership for a better future. 

 

Y'all, the scope of this novel is extraordinary. Never once, in the 700+ pages, did I think that it was too long or wish for it to end faster. It was a page-turning rollercoaster of emotions and nonstop action (violence and tension and kidnapping and politics and loss and grief and so much drama) from start to finish. There was all the violence and political maneuvering that we've gotten used to, but with messy and complex and deeply human relationships (Shae and Woon, Hilo and Wen, Niko and his whole family/legacy, Ayt Mada and Shea, Anden and his role within the family) smoothly interwoven into everything.  I didn't have any inkling how much time we'd traverse throughout this novel, but watching the next generation come into their own was an unexpected bonus. We only get her as a primary focus towards the end, but I loved Jaya's fire, like a young Hilo. Across the board, the way the Hilo and Wen's kids "aged up" was fun to watch, and watching the young generation we met at the beginning becoming "old hats" was fulfilling in its own ways. 

 

Worth mentioning: I cried for a single death in this entire series (and there were so many) but when it happened, I full-on sobbed, I was that invested. But other than that, I don't really want to say too much more about the plot itself, the relationships and growing up and deaths and subplots and plot twists, because the journey is one that I want everyone to take fresh and clear-eyed, like I did. Suffice it to say, that *a lot* happens and it's the edge-of-your-seat type stuff mixed with complicated machinations that Lee has shown herself to be a master of. Honestly, Lee’s ability to create such complex growth, with so many moving pieces and all the meandering and complex paths and decisions of the characters, and pull it all back together perfectly for this stunning finish (with nothing getting lost) is so impressive. 

 

Side note: I have been waiting through this entire series to see where Bero’s story finally goes and it delivered, but in a really unexpected way. Like, he was part of a major moment, but not at all the way I (or he) expected, and it easily could have been a kind of letdown. Yet, his subplot gave fascinating insight into the way the rest of the “normal” people in Kekon dealt with the excessive "slow war" and clan based war stuff in a way that was a great narrative balance and perspective. 

 

Thematically, I thought what Lee did as the story got darker, in addressing the harder truths of always dealing in death and violence, the mental health aspects, was an intense (but necessary) piece of this closing book. I also really appreciated that, as the war over jade became more widespread, the fight over control of the market and its approved uses/roles was fought both in military and political spaces, above and below ground, in a frighteningly familiar demonstration of the privatization and monopolization of war (through governments, mercenaries, criminal leaders and more), and the way that civilians are caught in the crossfire so often in modern warfare as a result. Plus, the way this modernization of war brings in so many platforms that were hitherto "out of bounds," like cinema, medicine, athletics, and in the court of public opinion into the game as actual difference makers was also really accurate to real life and added dimension to the breadth of the novel. 

 

I was here for the culmination of feuds closed, but with the twist of future generations being better and moving forwards. The way Lee balanced holding on to traditions that are important and the backbone of culture in a way that is safer and more accepting and truly opens options for a new future, but within the cradle of respect and honor for the past, gives the reader a lot of hope for what's to come in our own future, tbh. And what a gorgeous bringing together of how the depth of ties and support of family are, in the end, what makes a person powerful, as opposed to the more measurable/objective power of money and influence (and can, in fact, lead to the latter, in a stronger way).  

 

In the Acknowledgements at the end, Lee writes that this is the “epic urban fantasy gangster family saga of my heart” and OMG was it ever. It was the epic urban fantasy gangster family saga that my heart didn't even know it wanted/needed and I loved every minute of it. What a f*cking finale - breathtaking - this is how you  bring a spectacular series to a spectacular conclusion and I could not recommend it more highly.  

 

“No one is destined to become like their parents. In fact, we can learn from their mistakes and be less likely to repeat them. […] You’re your own person, Niko. You have many people who love you and are proud of you.” 

 

“Why not escape reality, when it was so unbearably cruel to wives and sisters and mothers?” 

 

“…he’d imagined that the foreigners were right - the world of Green Bones was brutal and outdated, nothing like the rest of the world. Now he knew better. There was jade and blood and cruelty everywhere.” 

 

“Clans and jade, murder and vengeance, burdens and feuds and failures passed down from father to brother to son - none of it was a myth…”