Reviews

The Great God Pan Illustrated by Arthur Machen

wimploe's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Often what separates good books from great ones is imagery. Good books present excellent imagery. They easily allow the reader to paint a picture similar to that which the author is intending to portray. However, great books leave out just enough, letting the reader fill in the blank with their imagination. They become enthralled with all the possibilities. Voraciously devouring each page of the book to discover more. The greedy book tightens its grip, desperately holding on, always leaving the reader wanting for more. A great story leaves desperation in its wake. Feeding just enough scraps to keep from starvation, yet aching, yearning for more. In the end, one is left combing through their mind. Analyzing everything they just read. Trying to discover small details they may have missed within the scraps they were given.

Recommend finding a dark, quiet room with a small lamp that gives off barely enough light to read by.

jon288's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Twisted victorian horror of the unknowable old gods. Not bad as it goes and worth a read, but nothing amazing. Probably groundbreaking for the time though? And some effective suspense

snazzy10101's review against another edition

Go to review page

challenging dark slow-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? It's complicated
  • Loveable characters? It's complicated
  • Diverse cast of characters? No
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.5

I started this ages ago cuz I found out about The Great God Pan. 
After reading that story (which is 5/5), I did some research on Machen and discovered we would not have gottten along. Funny how a man from the late 1800’s who hated women managed to write a piece of Good For Her, feminist horror. However although I loved it, I did have to sit with it for a while to gain any meaning from it (not that meaning is essential, it can just be a fun journey).

Novel of the White Powder 5/5
This is a much shorter story which reads like a drug trip and could be a metaphor for our capitalist society. what started with corruption ends with corruption. The meaning of this one jumps right out at you. 

The Red Hand (dnf)
Here is where Machen’s prose begins to take a toll. It was all too much and I couldn’t finish it. This resulted in me putting the book for months.

The White People 4/5
I picked this book back up again for the final story as I am currently reading The Twisted Ones by T Kingfisher and I wanted to read the original before I continued their version. This one doesn’t hit as hard as Pan but Machen’s never ending sentences add to the overall experience of the unknown magic(??)(it could just be how nature truely is honestly) and I loved the depiction of good/evil and saints/sinners. 

ipanzica's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

A short yet terrifying read

booksofgayle's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.5

Et Diabolus incarnatus est. Et homo factus est.
"And the Devil was made incarnate. And was made man."

a nice lil playlist to capture the vibe🤭:
🎵 Menhir Ginger -  Musica Chthulthiana
🎵 Dr. Gorgo - Musica Chthulthiana
🎵 Anguish - Aseptic Void
🎵 Rest Easy - Tobias Lilja

Pros
  • The prose is absolutely fucking beautiful. machen somehow manages to make environments both eerie and lush at the same time (feels kinda like Conrad's Heart of Darkness but set in rural Wales and 1890's London)
  • I love the way he makes two very separated time periods mix by making the ruins of an ancient pagan temple bleed into the modern streets of London and giving us a feel of wrongness about that, like the whole pan thing is out of its time.
  • ~fuck around and find out~ my favorite horror trope 🫶 
  • i'm not in the occult club but in the end I’m a bitch for it and so I can’t help but stan the idea of an anti-christ girlie, hell yeea⛧
  • pretty great use of the unknown/unseen/unmentionable as the main horror element – nothing scarier than an unknown malevolence imo. (not perfectly done tho because it was definitely tipping over into being too much at times)
  • the whole revelation of
    Mary being the mother of Helen and Helen essentially being the anti-christ
    caught me completely off-guard. that was cool. so glad I went in blind
  • All the underlying symbolism I could probably spend hours digging into – for example
    using Mary as her name because she's the mother of Helen by Pan/Satan just like Mary is the mother of Jesus by God.
     
  • if this was an indie pixel horror game then clarke's bachelor apartment would be a warm and cozy save station
  • I dig the shortness of it, it really doesn’t need to be longer. and the fact that it’s so short kind of smooths out the cons
 
Cons 
  • a little bit anticlimatic because the ending feels kinda subdued when it's just told in retrospective like that
  • ngl I was a lil confused with the shifting povs of that handful of dudes, I wonder if it could've been written with fewer povs altogether?
  • this may be my fault for not concentrating enough idk but I had a continuously poor perception of how much time was passing😂 (but maybe that was intentional?? because it definitely made the revelation hit harder lol)
  • A little wordy in the middle but not terrible

overall a diamond in the rough but i loved it👌

The universe is silent throughout the day, and not without dread has it been sundered; it shines with nightly fires, and resounds on all sides from the choruses of the Aegipans: both the playing of pipes, and the ringing of cymbals are heard along the ocean shore.

aeliasus's review against another edition

Go to review page

dark mysterious tense fast-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? It's complicated
  • Loveable characters? It's complicated

4.5

raisinbrandon3's review against another edition

Go to review page

dark mysterious tense medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? No
  • Loveable characters? No
  • Diverse cast of characters? No
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

4.0

blatdriver's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

I enjoyed this, I was expecting a gothic fantisy, but it's more gothic horror, with a little lovecraftian fantisy in it, it is a bit wordy at times, but that is to be expected for it's age.

arekusu16's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

Un poco meh, sinceramente.

No tenía muchas expectativas, pero no me ha gustado mucho.

parhelion's review against another edition

Go to review page

dark mysterious

5.0